Wednesday, June 14, 2006

Is this Kefirah?

My father-in-law, the wit, is fond of pointing out that the Hasidim have a biblical source for their bizzare pronunciaton scheme. In Gen 4:18 Irad's son is named once as Mechooyael and once as Mecheeyal. [For the Hasidim, every "oo" is said "ee"]

I'm not sure when the thought that this discrepancy in Gen 4:18 might be an a error first occured to me. Probably, I was a teenager fresh from reading The Promise, Potok's account of an Orthodox rabinical student's effort to reconcile the outside world with the world of halacha.

From time to time, I've stumbled across other evidence that some of the Torah was muddled during the long years of handwritten transmission. Like Potok's character I've struggled to reconcile this information with the halachic reality, and the theological insistance that this absolutely could not have occured.

I'm not alone. Here, for example, is Menachem Cohen, Professor of Bible at Bar-Ilan University, discussing how a religious community should deal with textual discrepancies:

Gen. 46:13 reads: "And the sons of Issacar are Tola and Puah and Yov and Shomron." The third name on the list, Yov arouses some doubt as to its accuracy, in light of the following: In Num.26:24 the name is given as "Yashuv"; In the Samaritan version of the verse in Genesis, as well as in the Septuagint, the name is Yashuv; I Chron.7:6 in the MT reads: "And the children of Issacar are Tola and Puah, Yashiv (Qere: Yashuv) and Shomron, four sons." These facts lead us to the conclusion that Issachar's son was indeed called Yashuv, and that Yov is an error which crept in to the transmission of the MT before sanctified status was granted to its consonantal base. A modern religious commentary will not have fulfilled its obligation to its readers if it did not bring these facts and their like to their attention. Nevertheless, the historical conclusion is to be kept separate from the question of writing a Sefer Torah. Since the spelling has been sanctified together with the sanctification of the Authorized Text of the MT, anyone who changes one letter of this word invalidates the Torah scroll, as only this spelling has validity and carries halakhic weight when writing a Sefer Torah.
The discrepancy, in Professor Cohen's view is an error, but an error that has been institutionalized; as a result we're stuck with it.

I find his line of thinking appealing. It's sensible, honest, and respects both halacha and reality.

BUT IS IT KEFIRAH?

No. It's well-established that many of our Sages were of the opinion that our Torah is not a letter-for-letter match with the Torah Moshe received at Sinai. Furthermore, it's also well known that the Rambam's famous declaration that the Torah was unchanged was part of a polemic response to Muslim claims that Jews had edited out the story of God's permanent rejection fo the Jewish people following the Golden Calf episode.

DIGRESSION

I know it won't be easy for some of you to accept what I've said about the Rambam, but consider this: Rambam was a Rishon, not God, and not Moshe Rabbeinu. I don't know, how his ikkarim managed to cause so much irrational, obsessive-compulsive behavior, when some of them were contextual polemics, and when they were the opinion of just one man. Other Rishonim disagreed with him heartily, and some of his works were burned by other Rishonim! Was everyone on the anti-Maimonidean side of the controversy a kofer? And did they all accept the Ikkarim, blindly and unflinchingly?

Furthermore, were the baalei haTosfot kofrim? They were well aware of transmission errors, said so explicitly and called attention to them!

END DIGRESSION

77 comments:

Anonymous said...

buy ambien ambien overdose limit - online pharmacy reviews ambien

Anonymous said...

buy valium online effects of valium for anxiety - valium online topix

Anonymous said...

order lorazepam best place buy ativan - can buy ativan online

Anonymous said...

diazepam 5mg diazepam withdrawal death - diazepam effects erowid

Anonymous said...

cheap alprazolam 1.5 mg xanax overdose - zany bars xanax

Anonymous said...

ativan 2mg ativan and xanax taken together - ativan high mg

Anonymous said...

zolpidem 10 mg what is zolpidem er 12.5 - buy zolpidem online no prescription

Anonymous said...

ativan online lorazepam 1 mg reviews - known side effects ativan

Anonymous said...

buy xanax online xanax dosage epocrates - xanax withdrawal fever

Anonymous said...

is lorazepam stronger than diazepam buy diazepam no prescription usa - diazepam 2mg when to take

Anonymous said...

where can i order xanax online can you buy alprazolam - xanax bars alp

Anonymous said...

xanax online no prescription xanax withdrawal clonidine - clonazepam generic xanax

Anonymous said...

buy generic ativan ativan drug vs xanax - ativan withdrawal wiki

Anonymous said...

how to buy xanax online greenstone alprazolam 0.5mg - xanax dosage how long does it last

Anonymous said...

zolpidem without prescription side effects of zolpidem ambien - ambien cr 12.5 alcohol

Anonymous said...

carisoprodol drug buy soma arizona - soma drug in brave new world

Anonymous said...

soma pills can u overdose carisoprodol - soma online cheap

Anonymous said...

buy diazepam where can i buy valium online yahoo answers - diazepam 10 mg farmacias ahumada

Anonymous said...

He that makes a thing too fine, breaks it.

5oBbg http://www.cheapuggbootsan.com/
uRdi http://www.michaelkorsoutletez.com/
mCkq http://www.cheapfashionshoesam.com/
4xHxx http://www.burberryoutletxi.com/
5bMss http://www.nflnikejerseysshopxs.com/
2mEkd http://www.coachfactoryoutlesa.com/
4wNig 1sJzn 0nLot 7eRap 8fNta 8xJcz 7jOdv 9uPpa 0sXsa

Anonymous said...

Blogger: DOVBEAR - Post a Comment order prednisolone - purchase prednisone http://www.ourdailybreadmarket.net/#purchase-prednisone

Anonymous said...

Blogger: DOVBEAR - Post a Comment ativan sale - buy cheap ativan online http://www.ativanonlineoffer.com/#buy-cheap-ativan-online

Anonymous said...

Blogger: DOVBEAR - Post a Comment buy meridia - meridia online http://www.meridiaordernow.com/#meridia-online

Anonymous said...

Blogger: DOVBEAR - Post a Comment lorazepam without rx - cheap lorazepam http://www.ativanonlineoffer.com/#cheap-lorazepam

Anonymous said...

Blogger: DOVBEAR - Post a Comment generic ativan - buy ativan online without prescription http://www.ativanonlineoffer.com/#buy-ativan-online-without-prescription

Anonymous said...

Hi, MoxoredapeTox roaccutane price - purchase accutane http://www.josoclasolucio.com/#cheap-accutane-no-prescription

Anonymous said...

Hi, MoxoredapeTox buy generic imitrex online - buy cheap imitrex http://www.oparticular.net/#buy-cheap-imitrex

Anonymous said...

Hello, cheap accutane - accutane no prescription http://www.josoclasolucio.com/#generic-isotretinoin

Anonymous said...

Drug And Alcohol Free Workplace prednisone cost - prednisone drug http://www.prednisone4sale.com/#prednisone-drug

Anonymous said...

Hello, cheap generic propecia - generic propecia no prescription http://www.bigdocpoker.com/#finasteride-online-pharmacy

Anonymous said...

Identity Of Rx Pills acomplia no prescription - generic rimonabant http://www.buydiscountedisotretinoin.net/#generic-rimonabant

Anonymous said...

No Side Effects Diet Pills order acomplia - buy acomplia no prescription http://www.buydiscountedisotretinoin.net/#buy-acomplia-no-prescription

Anonymous said...

What Is Ptt In Medicine acomplia weight loss - order acomplia online http://www.buydiscountedisotretinoin.net/#order-acomplia-online

Anonymous said...

Hello, accutane without rx - buy roaccutane http://www.josoclasolucio.com/#isotretinoin-cost

Anonymous said...

Tu Pac Selling Drugs buy acomplia online no prescription - acomplia for sale http://www.buydiscountedisotretinoin.net/#acomplia-for-sale

Anonymous said...

Hello, cheap generic lipitor - order lipitor http://www.costoflipitoronline.net/#order-lipitor

Anonymous said...

Antimalarial Drugs Hyperpigmentation Mucosa order topamax no prescription - buy topiramate http://www.topamaxdiscount.com/

Anonymous said...

Medication For Sibo order topamax - buy topamax without prescription http://www.topamaxbetterprice.com/

Anonymous said...

Facts About Drug Safety diazepam online no prescription - valium price http://www.samskitchenonline.com/, [url=http://www.samskitchenonline.com/]cheap diazepam [/url]

Anonymous said...

Integrative Medicine Duke Antoinette Pierce generic imitrex no prescription - imitrex no prescription http://www.brawr.net/ - [url=http://www.brawr.net/]imitrex cost [/url]

Anonymous said...

Identify Rx Medication Free meridia weight loss - meridia sale http://www.meridiaonlineorder.net/#meridia-sale , [url=http://www.meridiaonlineorder.net/#order-meridia ]order meridia [/url]

Anonymous said...

No Perscription Drug sibutramine online - sibutramine for sale http://www.meridiaonlineorder.net/#sibutramine-for-sale , [url=http://www.meridiaonlineorder.net/#buy-meridia ]buy meridia [/url]

Anonymous said...

2, cheap ambien no prescription - cheap ambien online http://www.opensourcewcms.com/#cheap-ambien-online , [url=http://www.opensourcewcms.com/#order-zolpidem ]order zolpidem [/url]

Anonymous said...

tfv clomid for sale without prescription - order clomiphene http://www.clomidonlinediscount.net/#cheap-clomid, [url=http://www.clomidonlinediscount.net/#cheap-clomid]order clomid no prescription [/url]

Anonymous said...

tfv clomiphene price - clomid pills http://www.clomidonlinediscount.net/#cheap-clomid, [url=http://www.clomidonlinediscount.net/#cheap-clomid]cheap clomid no prescription [/url]

Anonymous said...

3. topamax price - order topamax no prescription http://www.polymathinnovationgroup.com/#order-topamax-no-prescription , [url=http://www.polymathinnovationgroup.com/#buy-topiramate ]buy topiramate [/url]

Anonymous said...

6, adipex generic - cheap adipex http://www.costofadipex375.com/#cheap-adipex-37.5 mg, [url=http://www.costofadipex375.com/#cheap-adipex]cheap adipex online[/url]

Anonymous said...

6, klonopin for sale - cheap clonazepam http://www.klonopinsaleonline.com/#klonopin-for-sale, [url=http://www.klonopinsaleonline.com/#klonopin-online-sale]generic klonopin online[/url]

Anonymous said...

ooo!!! Order Topamax - buy topiramate http://www.topamaxbestonline.net/#topamax-cost, [url=http://www.topamaxbestonline.net/#topamax-cost]Topamax Online[/url]

Anonymous said...

ooo!!! Topamax Online - topiramate 25mg http://www.topamaxbestonline.net/#buy-topamax, [url=http://www.topamaxbestonline.net/#buy-topamax]Topamax Cost[/url]

Anonymous said...

ooo!!! Topamax For Sale - order topamax online no prescription http://www.cheaptopamaxorder.net/#cheap-topamax, [url=http://www.cheaptopamaxorder.net/#cheap-topamax]Topamax Online[/url]

Anonymous said...

2013 generic lorazepam - order ativan online no prescription http://www.ativanonlinenorx.net/#generic-lorazepam, [url=http://www.ativanonlinenorx.net/#buy-ativan]buy ativan[/url]

Anonymous said...

2013 ativan online pharmacy - order ativan http://www.ativanonlinenorx.net/#cheap-lorazepam-2mg, [url=http://www.ativanonlinenorx.net/#buy-ativan]cheap lorazepam 2mg[/url]

Anonymous said...

2, finasteride online - finasteride 5mg http://www.propeciasaleonline.net/#propecia-sale, [url=http://www.propeciasaleonline.net/#propecia-sale]propecia cost[/url]

Anonymous said...

g, Biology Project - http://www.onlinewritinghelp101.com/biology.html#biology-online, [url=http://www.onlinewritinghelp101.com/biology.html#biology-assignments]Biology Assignments[/url]

Anonymous said...

ny, vardenafil without prescription - order levitra online http://www.recoverinchrist.org/#order-levitra-online , [url=http://www.recoverinchrist.org/#buy-levitra ]buy levitra [/url]

Anonymous said...

Hi, homework helper online - science homework helper http://2012thewaiting.com/homework.html, [url=http://2012thewaiting.com/homework.html]homework helpers online [/url]

Anonymous said...

Hi, generic cymbalta 60 mg - buy duloxetine http://www.13725380889.com/#discount-cymbalta, [url=http://www.13725380889.com/#cymbalta-price]cymbalta medication [/url]

Anonymous said...

Hi, buy generic provigil - cheap provigil online http://mawuyogaangels.com/, [url=http://mawuyogaangels.com/]modafinil cost [/url]

Anonymous said...

4, generic for strattera - generic for strattera medication http://www.stratterafastonline.net/, [url=http://www.stratterafastonline.net/]buy atomoxetine online [/url]

Anonymous said...

4, generic strattera - buy atomoxetine online http://www.stratterabenefits.net/#strattera-sale, [url=http://www.stratterabenefits.net/#atomoxetine-online-pharmacy]order strattera[/url]

Anonymous said...

4, generic modafinil - modafinil for sale http://www.energyofprovigil.net/#generic-modafinil, [url=http://www.energyofprovigil.net/#provigil-online-pharmacy]provigil for sale[/url]

Anonymous said...

4, order strattera - strattera online pharmacy http://www.stratterabenefits.net/#order-strattera, [url=http://www.stratterabenefits.net/#generic-strattera]generic strattera[/url]

Anonymous said...

3, [url=http://www.maxaltonlinehelp.net/] Cheap Maxalt[/url] - Maxalt Online - cheap maxalt online http://www.maxaltonlinehelp.net/.

Anonymous said...

1, [url=http://www.onlinecelebrexdeal.net/]Cheap Celebrex[/url] - Celecoxib Cost - celebrex for sale online http://www.onlinecelebrexdeal.net/.

Anonymous said...

3, [url=http://www.lunestabenefits.net/] Lunesta For Sale [/url] - Order Eszopiclone - lunesta sale http://www.lunestabenefits.net/.

Anonymous said...

2, [url=http://www.doesprozacwork.net/]Fluoxetine Online[/url] - Generic Fluoxetine - fluoxetine online no prescription http://www.doesprozacwork.net/.

Anonymous said...

purchase accutane - cheap accutane no prescription http://www.isotretinoinonsale.net/, [url=http://www.isotretinoinonsale.net/]cheap accutane[/url]

Anonymous said...

generic accutane - isotretinoin online pharmacy http://www.isotretinoinonsale.net/, [url=http://www.isotretinoinonsale.net/]accutane for sale[/url]

Anonymous said...

6, [url=http://www.stratterarxcoupon.net/]Order Strattera Online[/url] - Strattera For Sale - generic strattera http://www.stratterarxcoupon.net/ .

Anonymous said...

6, [url=http://www.stratterarxcoupon.net/]Order Strattera Online[/url] - Buy Strattera Online - strattera sale http://www.stratterarxcoupon.net/ .

Anonymous said...

5, [url=http://www.stratterarxcoupon.net/]Buy Strattera Online[/url] - Buy Strattera Online - strattera sale http://www.stratterarxcoupon.net/ .

Anonymous said...

5, [url=http://www.nexiumpricewatch.net/] Esomeprazole Online [/url] - Nexium No Prescription - cheap nexium http://www.nexiumpricewatch.net/ .

Anonymous said...

6, [url=http://www.costofeffexor.net/]Order Effexor Online[/url] - Effexor Online - effexor 75 http://www.costofeffexor.net/

Anonymous said...

5, [url=http://www.costofeffexor.net/]Order Effexor Online[/url] - Order Effexor Online - buy venlafaxine xr http://www.costofeffexor.net/ .

Anonymous said...

6, [url=http://www.cheapzoloftrx.net/] Generic Zoloft [/url] - Order Zoloft Online - zoloft cost http://www.cheapzoloftrx.net/ .

Anonymous said...

11, [url=http://www.solarcraftaudio.com/]gabapentin online[/url] - gabapentin online - gabapentin price http://www.solarcraftaudio.com/ .

Anonymous said...

14, [url=http://www.tiptheserver.com/] Order Klonopin [/url] - Klonopin Sale - klonopin without rx http://www.tiptheserver.com/ .