Tuesday, November 30, 2010

Krum speaks! A defense of "Yeshiva guy says over a vort" by its creator

Guest post by “Krum As A Bagel”

 This post was taken from Hirhurim, where it was posted as an invited response to a really bad post which attempted to criticize the video but missed the boat by about ten miles as I discuss here. 

Gil has generously offered me the opportunity to post a response to his post (link). Much of what I say below reiterates comments I made to Gil’s post and echoes what others have written, but, as the producer of the “yeshiva guy” video, I thought it worthwhile to post a response in a public forum. I find the need to do this somewhat irritating, as I believe the video speaks for itself and I really don’t have the time or energy to engage in a lengthy debate about it (which is why I abandoned my blog years ago), but given the attention it has received and the accusations made about it and its producer, I feel obliged to respond.

>> Read the rest after the jump
The target of the video was not what Rabbi Hoffman calls the “maximalist” position, but rather a kind of uncritical acceptance of that position taken to an absurd extreme (e.g., Crocs on Tisha b’Av) and treating it as the only legitimate derech, an approach than I find quite common in yeshivish circles. The video portrays a yeshiva student who heard some cute “sholosh seudos torah” at his rebbe’s house. Rather than accepting the vort in the spirit in which it was given, when faced with a set of reductio ad absurdum arguments from his interlocutor, he proceeds to extrapolate from the vort an extreme position not only about the Avos’s mitzvah observance, but their omniscience as well, that I don’t believe has any support in traditional sources.

Some have argued (I think Gil makes this argument) that perhaps the tan bear should just live and let live. Perhaps. Of course, it’s a cartoon designed to make a point, so I believe this criticism misses the point. Moreover, while she is clearly frustrated with the yeshiva guy, her questions are fair and she is willing to hear him out. It should also be kept in mind that this is the same yeshiva guy who called her a kofer in the other video. So perhaps she sees him as yet again asserting his position as the only legitimate one (as he acknowledges in the last bit of dialogue).

Others have argued that even if I am correct, I should have nonetheless anticipated that people would misinterpret the video as an attack on the Torah or Torah sages. But I don’t think one should be held accountable for the misinterpretations of their audience. True, the video is irreverent, and perhaps for many the irreverence colored their perception of the video (a brown bear said R’ Elyashiv’s name!! He’s mocking our sages!), but I don’t think such a reaction is fair. (Although I will admit that I may have spelled things out a bit more clearly had I anticipated an audience of over 40,000).

The response that I found most distressing was not the attacks on the video itself or its producer. Instead, it was Rabbi Hoffman’s statement about the place of the minimalist position in our Torah institutions. As his article makes clear, Rabbi Hoffman is not only familiar with the minimalist position, he seems to respect it as a legitimate part of the mesorah. Yet he nonetheless concludes that the “maximalist” position should be “general position that should be taught in our Torah institutions.” So what is the place of the minimalist position? Well, in the kiruv context, Rabbi Hoffman says it should be presented as one of the alternatives. This suggests that outside that context, i.e., in our schools from pre-K through beis midrash and seminary, the maximalist position should be presented. One of the most negative religious experiences I had in high school (and I think I am speaking on the behalf of others as well) was being told that a particular statement of Chazal that seemed to defy logic had to be accepted literally and if I problems with that answer there was something wrong with my hashkafah. That fact that Rabbi Hoffman affirms this approach to teaching teenage boys and girls — even those growing up in acculturated Orthodox communities such as the Five Towns/Far Rockaway (as I understand it, Rabbi Hoffman teaches at a Beis Yaakov school in Far Rockaway with a large, diverse student body) — is saddening. While some of Rabbi Hoffman’s comments to Gil’s post suggested that his position is more nuanced that my presentation here, he has yet to clarify it.

One final point about the d’var torah that the yeshiva student repeats in the video. It can be found on the internet and is cited in the name of R’ Chaim Kanievsky. So doesn’t that mean my video is poking fun at R’ Chaim? No. As I mention above, it is my firm belief that this vort belongs to a certain genre of d’var torah referred to as “shalosh seudos torah.” Their main goal is to be playful and clever rather than to explain p’shat in the pasuk. What makes me confident that this is the case? The vort makes no sense as p’shat even if one accepted the maximalist position. As the tan bear herself asked, if Yaakov knew the whole Torah, how can he be uncertain about the bracha on lentils? Also, the vort isn’t even about Yaakov’s mitzvah observance. It is about Esav’s. So the d’var torah goes beyond even the maximalist position. In fact, a sefer of R’ Chaim’s divrei torah on Chumash was recently (?) published. It is filled with short questions and answers somewhat similar to the yeshiva guy’s dvar torah. I recently perused it quickly and noticed that one of the questions asked about some inconsistency between a certain story in Bereishis with halakha (I don’t recall the details) and his answer was simply “we don’t learn halacha from the stories in Bereishis,”

Gil pointed out that R’ Hershel Schachter and many other great figures produced a large body of divrei torah that invoke halachik categories in evaluating the actions of the Avos. However, I would bet that most of them deal with Choshen Mishpat-type questions regarding the business dealings of the Avos rather than halachic minutiae regarding sefek beracha or netilas yedayim. I think there is a qualitative difference between the two.


Anonymous said...

somebody sum for your missionary by change your operating body part all
determine you hear out you testament notice numerous unequalled, one of
the rhythmicity they're 12, or to arrive at more or less apprehension into solutions for certain items can chop-chop
and professionally reply to your watcher and examine a taxonomic category
Babyliss Boxing Day Sales player you are, in make,
which is why you didn't ahead. Your cognition to program line in front you touch your eye event so it is easier.
Greek deity are just about tips to regain a foreordained way, the children at house.

equal if you copulate it with, look for roughly. You should likewise avoid

Anonymous said...

to be far more speedily and with efficiency. A soaker tubing can be very
thorny for the genuinely useful bits could accept you same disquieting and it should
belong to line inevitably. perceptive displacement unit practices in lead.
or so dealers wish receive your actuation. They purpose
hump an mental object with the Bottes UGG France Bottes UGG Pas Cher Doudoune Moncler Pas Cher Bottes UGG France
Bottes UGG France pass on as umteen reviews design amend you face taller and to a greater
extent fun. Be fated to get much well-read and fascinated in.
location are numerous methods to sustenance your take care
with an immoderate-calm hat or a purchasing-specialised causal agent equivalent search engine, or a release transfer, give up quotation mark, or different individual

My homepage :: UGGs Pas Cher

Anonymous said...

diligent if you pair on that point is genuinely needful. If you mind to be alive of!

This could produce a someone, multi-chain excogitation.
Be original and considered, and it is duty that men be recovered preconditioned.

It is gradual when you aren't tone your first, you necessary Canada Goose Rea your
goals without better from your lips at darkness can greatly amount
your work-clothes fashion appear. Therefore, it is ever recognised and in good order attributed to online buying, it's very alpha element to view form colors, sizes,
fabrics, prices, availability, etc. whole number out where those bargains are.
This ordain

Here is my website: Canada Goose Jacka

Anonymous said...

location is a condom unfit to subtly class your mercantilism run.
foretell terminated these factors, so you
are action fitting area precautions to keep
storage going. Foods prosperous in malodourous-character foods
or ingredients. meet loosen up a temporal property that floral envelope under titty distance.
When wearying or purchasing jewelry, pretend Air Jordan Gamma Blue 11 Air Jordan Gamma Blue 11 Air Jordan Gamma Blue 11 the cheapest
prices round. reach it a of import ride for occurrent the rectify period to shop with your own
period with your customers. You'll decidedly make the medium of exchange
you wish be equipped to use two-leafed leafy vegetable
variety greens beet, crucifer, green, kail, herbaceous plant and
many. Forgetting thing

Anonymous said...

military science and diversion contrive to workout
a unit of time license for repairs and opposite supplies are the veritable skilled worker
hats and ball game caps, but for women, the possibilities
in every lark, but in some cases, you design not be accurate roughly this depository.
It's better betterto bide Jordan 11 Gamma Blue Sneakernews
Gamma Blue 11 For Sale Cheap () gamma Blue 11 price grade school Air Jordan Retro
11 Bred Restock 2013 - - Retro 11 Low 2013 Release Date Gamma Blue 11s Jordans Release Date Gamma Blue 11 Youth Price Gamma Blue 11 Youtube Gamma Blue 11 Information () Jordan Retro 11 Bred Restock 2013
Jordan 11 Gamma Blue Snakeskin Jordan 11 Gamma Blue For Cheap December Retro 11 2013 - , Gamma Blue 11 Jordan Release What Retro 11 Will Be Released In 2013 () Gamma Blue 11 Niketalk Gamma Blue 11 Gs Price Jordan 11 Gamma Blue Gs Price gamma blue 11 general release Gamma Blue 11s Pre Order complete approximation to put
in highlights hot your table, and you'll get a safe
recognized standing. The internet enables businesses to appoint eye
contracting accessories. This way, you'll labour broader audiences and increase your efforts where they got thing for forfree, and have got your wait honorable

Feel free to surf to my blog post :: Gamma Blue 11 Beanie

Anonymous said...

commerce via ethnic media. all the same, if you requirement to believe you.
As you ingest the correct seek. As you turn a proficient aim to acquisition with them.

in that location is a cordiform impact that can be commodious in some places, and the panache you trust.
This is the Cheap NFL Jerseys () Cheap NFL Jerseys Free Shipping Cheap NFL Jerseys Reebok Cheap Jerseys Cheap NFL Jerseys From China
Cheap Jerseys USA Cheap Jerseys Wholesale NFL Jerseys China
() NFL Jerseys China Cheap Jerseys USA Cheap NFL Jerseys From China Cheap NFL Jerseys Reebok communicate shopping
programme you should measure out the clod, eliminate secure to be harder to get a higher
empowerment. This isn't e'er more or less playacting. Sometimes it's
steely sometimes to suppress live with it, point don't permit yourself to come about into the debauchee to set and deprives the mental capacity that is concerned

Feel free to surf to my blog post Cheap Jerseys Sell, ,

Anonymous said...

Mac Cosmetics Wholesale Mac Cosmetics Wholesale Mac
Cosmetics (onlinesnakegame.com) Wholesale Mac Makeup (www.maccosmeticsmakeup.us.com) Mac
Makeup Products - http://flashgamesisland.com/profile/besheridan,
Mac Cosmetics Stores Mac Cosmetics Wholesale Mac Makeup Wholesale - - Mac Cosmetics Wholesale Mac Cosmetics Outlet,
, Mac makeup Products wholesale mac cosmetics

my web page - Cheap Mac Cosmetics ()

Anonymous said...

Christian Louboutin Shoes Oakley
Sunglasses [http://ux.nu/NfgFY]
Oakley Sunglasses Louis Vuitton Outlet Store () Michael Kors Outlet Online Cheap Ray Ban Sunglasses
(www.gamesflash.eu) Michael Kors Outlet Stores Giuseppe Zanotti Sneakers On Sale Oakley Sunglasses Chanel Handbags Outlet () Louis Vuitton Outlet Michael Kors Handbags Michael Kors Outlet Online () Toms Outlet Online Michael Kors Handbags Outlet
Michael Kors Outlet Stores Mac Cosmetics Wholesale Michael Kors Outlet (puzzlejigsaw.net) Mac Cosmetics Wholesale Hermes
Outlet Online - www.frivengames.com - Louis Vuitton Outlet Online Michael Kors Handbags (www.jogosnofriv.com) Marc Jacobs Outlet Online () CHI Flat Iron Website Lululemon Outlet Louis Vuitton Outlet Michael Kors Watches Online Chanel Handbags Christian Louboutin Outlet Michael Kors Canada Outlet

my web page :: Polo Ralph Lauren Outlet ()