Wednesday, March 16, 2011

Is Rabbi Fohrman's Purim Book Controversial?

A Guest Post By E. Fink

I just posted a quick review of a new book by Rabbi David Fohrman about Purim on my blog: Book Review | The Queen You Thought You Knew

There is something about this book that seems controversial. A rabbi whom I respect deeply was very offended by the book. His criticism was that the book basically ignores Chazal and appears to be more like an academic analysis of the megilla than a typical Torah style analysis found in yeshivos today.

This is true on both accounts. It is a more academic style and the academic style is not taught in yeshiva.

But is this style "wrong" or just unused by yeshivos? Does a dvar Torah or theory of Torah need sources in Chazal? Some say yes. There are Roshei Yeshiva whom I have heard say that unless something is "muchrach" it is not Torah. It's just opinion. It needs to fit in with existing knowledge and ideas to be true. On the other hand, the very heart of "chassidishe Torah" is it's absence of hachracha. It's all poetic reassurances of what is already believed to be true.

The fear of non-muchrach divrei Torah is that it undermines Chazal. It allows modern readers to use their modern ideas to interpret ancient words that have almost all been interpreted already using primary sources. If we can do it ourselves the argument goes, we are at risk of discarding Chazal, God forbid.

This puts bloggers like me in an interesting position. I am not a fan of "chassidishe Torah". I prefer my divrei Torah be built on at least some hachracha. I don't want Chazal to be undermined. But I also think I would enjoy the academic style of Torah study as well. In fact I did enjoy the book.

One would expect that the Charedi world that banned Rabbi Slifkin's books for undermining Chazal would vehemently oppose this book as well. "Academic study of Torah?! That's for kofrim. We have Chazal!"

Yet, the same Jonathan Rosenblum who supported the ban of Rabbi Slifkin's books, waxes poetic about Rabbi Fohrman's book. (http://www.mishpacha.com/Browse/Article/819/Outlook) I find that very interesting. In fact, the rabbi mentioned above is a big Rabbi Slifkin fan. How could one not be? Rabbi Slifkin simply quotes Chazal! But it could be argued, that Rabbi Fohrman in essence discards Chazal! According to the aforementioned rabbi, this is much worse. As evidence for this position one can simply look for approbations in the front of the book. There are none.

It will be interesting to see what will happen with this book. It is the first book I am aware of that implements the academic style of study in a book designed for charedim. Rabbi Etshalom has many divrei Torah in this style. Yet, I have never met a charedi who studied them.

It remains to be seen if this book will be accepted. And if it is accepted, what does that mean?

Buy the book today and get it in time for Purim here: The Queen You Thought You Knew

5 comments:

Anonymous said...

There is no garden without its weeds.

3oAcx http://www.cheapuggbootsan.com/
xVmd http://www.michaelkorsoutletez.com/
nQhv http://www.cheapfashionshoesam.com/
2pLxu http://www.burberryoutletxi.com/
2lZgt http://www.nflnikejerseysshopxs.com/
8aSzd http://www.coachfactoryoutlesa.com/
0dLgb 9nZnq 1tAio 4dBwq 7dBcl 2sJuv 4uCro 4nKpv 5gZol

Anonymous said...

There is no such thing as genius; it is nothing but labour and diligence.

5nRzu http://www.cheapuggbootsan.com/
tVjd http://www.michaelkorsoutletez.com/
hCbs http://www.cheapfashionshoesam.com/
9fYdr http://www.burberryoutletxi.com/
7nLvj http://www.nflnikejerseysshopxs.com/
2uGvv http://www.coachfactoryoutlesa.com/
7eBcg 3iZfe 8pInt 2dQal 9yWhu 8rTik 9eHvl 3fJek 3yHrm

Anonymous said...

ghd baratas kmdglflm ghd españa dpizjbei ghd planchas bfuuzkst ghd gioyudzy planchas ghd ugturepe

Anonymous said...

With havin so much content and articles do you ever run into any problems of plagorism
or copyright infringement? My site has a lot of unique content I've either written myself or outsourced but it looks like a lot of it is popping it up all over the web without my permission. Do you know any ways to help protect against content from being ripped off? I'd genuinely appreciate it.



Feel free to visit my web blog; Polo Outlet

Anonymous said...

Hi there everyone, it's my first go to see at this website, and post is actually fruitful designed for me, keep up posting these content.

Also visit my site; supra thunder