Tuesday, June 11, 2013

Everyone’s A Slave…

“You’re either a slave to Hashem or you’re a slave to your taivos.” How many times have we heard that? Most recently from our friend amos. It's one of the standard kiruv sound bites, and is a particularly grating one. It sounds profound, is meant to suggest that no one can be free, and that, as long as we’re all slaves, being a slave to God is better than being a slave to our desires. I think it’s time to put this banal assertion to rest.

Before I get to deconstructing the logic of the claim, here’s something funny. I wanted to find out where the idea comes from, so I typed “a slave to god or a slave to your desires” into Google. The first result is a passage from the New Testament, Romans 6:16-18:

Do you not know that to whom you present yourselves slaves to obey, you are that one’s slaves whom you obey, whether of sin leading to death, or of obedience leading to righteousness? But God be thanked that though you were slaves of sin, yet you obeyed from the heart that form of doctrine to which you were delivered. And having been set free from sin, you became slaves of righteousness.”

I went through a few pages of results and tried variations of the search phrase, and it really seems that this idea comes from the New Testament. How funny that Rebbonim and Roshei Yeshiva are giving mussar shmusen based on something written by the apostle Paul!

The claim itself is a false dichotomy. It suggests that there are only two choices. Either one does as Hashem commands, or one is a slave to his “taivos,”  which literally mean “desires” but in this context means “base desires:” pleasure, money, power, etc. As someone recently pointed out, even if it’s true that everyone is a slave to something, why would it have to be base desires? Someone could be a slave to his compassion, or his sense of justice, to caring for his family or to improving his community.

Hidden in the claim is another sound bite, the often-heard canard that without God, there is no morality, so of course if one doesn't enslave himself to God he will be overwhelmed by his base desires.  It’s not true that without God there’s no morality, but, more importantly, the notion that if someone isn't a slave to God he’ll be only concerned with fulfilling his base desires is demonstrably false. It’s just not true that non-religious people’s lives are non-stop orgies.

The corollary is also not true. Religious people are not free of their desires by virtue of being religious. There are religious people who are overwhelmed by their base drives. The idea is that you must be a slave to something; being a slave to your base desires is bad; so be a slave to God, which will prevent you from being enslaved by your desires. Yet one can be a slave to God AND a slave to his desires, so what is gained by being a slave to God?

In addition to being a false dichotomy, it also uses an equivocation fallacy. Being a slave to an intelligent Being and being a “slave” to your desires is not the same thing. Webster defines “slave” as:

1 : a person held in servitude as the chattel of another
2 : one that is completely subservient to a dominating influence

Neither is a  good situation to be in, but the first one is worse. Someone who is a slave to his desires may have serious problems, may even destroy his life, but he can, in theory, overcome his difficulties and regain control. Someone who is chattel is no longer someone in control of his own fate. He is property, just a thing to be used as his master sees fit.

I’m thinking about going through all the kiruv sound bites like this, and then create an index. Here's a short list:

  • You’re either a slave to Hashem or you’re a slave to your taivos.
  • Without Hashem, everything is hefker (there’s no morality without God).
  • There are no questions, only answers.
  • Our grandparents died for their beliefs.
  • You think you're smarter than (insert brilliant Rav here). [tesyaa]

And maybe some of the proofs?:

  • There’s an unbroken mesorah.
  • Our sifrie Torah are exactly the same as ones that are hundreds of years old / the same as what was handed to Moshe on Har Sinia,
  • The Kuzari.
  • The four-animal proof.
  • The longevity of the religion [Ksil] 
  • the mass belief in its tenants (i.e. muslims and Christians ALSO believe in the old testament [Ksil] 

Any more?

Cross-posted from my blog http://2nd-son.blogspot.com/2013/06/everyones-slave.html


Anonymous said...

Unquestionably believe that which you stated. Your favorite
justification seemed to be on the web the easiest thing to be aware of.
I say to you, I definitely get annoyed while people consider worries
that they plainly don't know about. You managed to hit the nail upon the top and also defined out the whole thing without having side effect , people could take a signal. Will probably be back to get more. Thanks

Feel free to visit my web site waist hip ratio calculator

Anonymous said...

Hey there! This is kind of off topic but I need some help from an established
blog. Is it difficult to set up your own blog? I'm not very techincal but I can figure things out pretty fast. I'm thinking
about making my own but I'm not sure where to begin. Do you have any tips or suggestions? Thanks

Feel free to visit my weblog ... raspberry Ketone Diet

Anonymous said...

I don't know whether it's just me or if perhaps everybody else experiencing issues with your website.
It appears as if some of the written text within your content
are running off the screen. Can someone else please comment and let me know
if this is happening to them as well? This could be a problem
with my browser because I've had this happen previously. Thanks

my weblog :: how much should i weigh for my age and height

Anonymous said...

Hey There. I discovered your blog the usage of msn. That is a very neatly written article.
I'll make sure to bookmark it and come back to read more of your useful information. Thank you for the post. I will definitely comeback.

My blog post Best diet Plans

Anonymous said...

I don't know whether it's just me or if everyone else encountering issues with your blog.
It looks like some of the text on your content are running off the screen.
Can someone else please comment and let me know if this is happening
to them too? This may be a problem with my web browser because I've had this happen before. Thank you

my homepage; registry cleaner software

Anonymous said...

My partner and I absolutely love your blog and find almost all of your post's to be just what I'm looking for.
Do you offer guest writers to write content for
you? I wouldn't mind publishing a post or elaborating on a few of the subjects you write regarding here. Again, awesome web log!

Feel free to surf to my weblog ... diet That Works

Anonymous said...

Most people know that citrus fruits are high in
vitamin C. You'll have a very hard time spotting anybody who's doing short fast cardio, also known as
burst training, interval training and HIIT (high intensity interval
training). Slow steady state walking on the treadmill or taking it easy on the way to work is not really going to work.
Spices (turmeric, oregano, thyme, rosemary, and sage).

Here is my homepage: Best Fat Burning Foods :: budocorners.com

Anonymous said...

This information is priceless. When can I find
out more?

My web blog; how to lose weight fast for women