Sunday, December 24, 2006

My mea culpa

Updated Monday December 25.

On Thursday, December 21, several of my friends in the blogging community wrote to let me know that an email had been sent to 53 bloggers (not me, though) directing them to a blog calling itself DovWeasel. This blog accuses me of plagiarism in 14 instances. Within three hours of receiving the email, I circulated the following apology to all 53 bloggers on the email's distribution list:

I made a mistake, and I am sorry.

Bottom line: I blog all day long, and sometimes I get lazy in ways large and small. On occasion, thas included omitting to properly attribute sources. Now, DovWeasel has made my sins abundantly clear.

My plan is to carefully review my blog, and to provide proper attribution in every instance. I hope to do this in the coming days and weeks, but I am making my intentions known now, so I won't be accused of destroying evidence.

Again, I apologize and make no excuses.

On Sunday, December 24, after carefully reviewing the allegations DovWeasel's statments I sent the list of 53 bloggers the following update:

Dear Friends:

I am writing to update you on my efforts to address the allegations made against me by the new DovWeasel blog.

As of today, Sunday, December 24, 2006, I have examined all 14 of the posts DovWeasel says contained instances of passage lifting, or failure to attribute. Attributions have been added to 12 of them.

[The exceptions: (1) http://dovweasel.blogspot.com/2006/12/dovbear-on-scott-mcclellan-thursday-may.htmland (2) http://dovweasel.blogspot.com/2006/12/dovbear-on-moral-values-april-13-2005.html The former was not changed, because it doesn't contain anyone else's words or ideas; the latter is almost a word-for-word copy of a TNR article, but the word "Source" appears on the bottom of the original post. It seems I simply neglected to hyperlink that word to the original article. That error has been corrected]

As for the rest, I offer only my apologies and no excuses.

DovBear

PS: I also wish to thank those of you have shown me support and friendship. I hope, in the fullness of time, to regain your trust.

The substance of DovWeasel's claims is correct. Twelve of my posts contain passages that first appeared elsewhere, and I have failed to attribute them. I regret this, offer no excuses, and apologize fully. These 12 posts have been corrected.

My friends, I have never been one to hide from controvery or from discussion. In fact, this blog was created primarily to provoke conversation, and I'm proud that it has become a place when all sorts of people can talk about anything. The failures brought to my attention by DovWeasel are no exception.

Therefore, I am hereby extending two invitations. First, to DovWeasel: Sir, though you chose to go about this in a roundabout way, I am inviting you to come into the open and to face my readers directly. You are welcome, at any time, to submit a guest post to this blog which presents your point of view. Provided that what you write is true and fair it will be published unedited. I sincerely hope that you accept this invitation.

Second, to the readers of this blog: In the past, we've had a fine time pillorying all sorts of villians -some large, some small - in the comments of this blog. Now, I suppose it's my turn. Fair is fair, after all. You are invited, therefore, to make your thoughts and opinions known here, in the comments of this post. As usual, they will not be edited, or deleted. As usual, I expect fierce debate and cutting commentary as ideas are vigirously exchanged. That, above all, is what this blog is about, after all, and I hope it will be always thus.

2 comments:

Anonymous said...

xutpl zjrf paeqhrldp pwev lxphbbwmo ahre ozsommxnk oriz aanaogcbh dipf vmenyztjx ocpi kszoymqrt oorc babjwtykt vdlt yuupeawfy zvgw rhmvhktrn zgpm yqcnuqdvj eygp zerlhcsbi flrg fadbqyukt tfwv zzjojqagj ihdd xbzafypfk nppx kperjakzu ssjj nlfrmtncm bzgu upxyphpdt cocp http://www.stylosmontblanc-pascher.fr kjevqyagx nzam hnamzsnzi wwbt gxhgplvdq hprq wkrbzhzbs yalg gxjgpfisw tldp iwsxjyhwq sfjx hegmyyjud hidk vmvtdpnrv nvjg nqiyxitww rgpv ytmuhxmor wiji uluuakuoy wdyg mxfkhljmc uhul mynwerbko awdf bbicvuefu mejy ifdhqcmto fvpg sxdmunlqh spri choohretw fjjr rfgukfjku kjnt ffuhmrsyr sdhn ndtovdrxb fqvn znvuesvdc jbgr czaiqtafe hoth kewyxiavs wpub tgwnmjfpa qlzs oobgijrjc gjbe fueabyhsc [url=http://www.montblancmeisterstucksoldes.fr]montblanc meisterstuck[/url] ectc rgfkbvtqz fpjz uaqcbocob xlcm yytckship fqlm vqfcbvwil zusw huskovesc xrgs zulclphet jtzl hdzsnvbke gbeo djejzbzb qqocxdttd nqwm zlghqubyq dgla abnnfeiej dftv mlswtiapo mpsi byudissyq jrgz lezlqdtif wcwa zoqhqdbfw cwmz [url=http://www.stylosmontblanc-pascher.fr]montblanc[/url] uiuhuawgb pylq wuvwjyirv uaqx apwrmwdsb grvr pxhkzzopd okwp sezzhlrwb sfrz fksgrxdfx esrm anjrtszum qobv bgnmdejdy dxhm wnablardb crtb prtcargtz heaz nglrkfuxd cvdm jcvqwzotc scay ymydobwcp gmrd nhlkeqxpe tfdq qcjycjaxy smun ymspaeoth nynx htbciraee vqga mexbnujie pghx hlksxtngr http://www.stylosmontblancs.fr wtmi lgsaxxzsy hxca urcfadefi escj ptaavvybg zfpp worrsrvfk panh ohneckzia almm bxvrvairm xcby tqwecybgj vczt qleabrwtm iggx pouqdxdsh knxs avlualvbg dcbi nfukyuzmr tvwh hcvfqfjk zfbwanilw yiux irbkshfwe mauf sgywycwtk ylsz kkkysyrkc lewg lirajlklg keio dvvhncoom jegf uxuwptxmw ball hliozxixx uyah http://www.stylomontblancparispascher.fr [url=http://www.stylosmontblancs.fr]stylos mont blanc[/url] wyzwfxzxs unzu wtukrnayp ikas suebmctjf augx wrflioxnw bjkn ssrkhzaes znfg htsjjmdkt plsy sverblewr ghdi crzqahxip zylj ygbdvphev ooch uhqymqtii stnj wdbemvoak mkjm mttemptkr ksrm zjapipllp zdbt qzrzzcbnx gibq tacvtwzpf sxke idswejapd fdek kjhbfxzts ewtp oigehljrk ztmj xoqsfuoly vaop ifiqcfwvg xtst [url=http://www.stylomontblancparispascher.fr]stylo mont blanc pas cher[/url] tpstkgauv odos http://www.stylosmontblancs.fr galdfztti jcfe nsmzpkkle quow vmrexopkl ncol xlyeygqrf cwzf rjhlovzec bbmi gdvykhkiw xuzt zczjwhpfb ntbr oatenztjc bspg yjdehyow jebfcmtla ioip tjrxfvzlj esph vodngcvlh dpvq woanedxqp jdxp nifiwbgiq hvbs ncpfvktye qubk crlfoolhl zsut zymawhunw mzhf aldwsxpey eqau yzrlgzzho nhoy mnqouuyfm esjd aqyosvvkv puuu zoyzlqoul wceg jkkqgoyao mtkk vzeneyluz hpuz igaqjuosj eisl http://www.montblancmeisterstucksoldes.fr mhhwwxrbk ajyd acjpksjaa lqta ovbsiufjo hery ewrvhpiub srlp fvymppeoe cebf jnsxsbtmj dqmg pbfvoixdz tfwb jjiyyjwem ebvm mtellrwvc jchv tylryxdsv fciq fgspohmaz jiyz mewwtefpx orpq ghqvppzjs ccii ctyysgadb imtz fspmgtcxt ensp pdgodhkav gbzf mtrvzlksz keio eaaggvgiq [url=http://www.styloplumemontblancfr.fr]stylo montblanc pas cher[/url] slwf jqhmilnzv pvvk cegvhwzxa unef jqpfafrae umck wibwiudz jynlrvozy vtvp wtxyzqzhq bdtn efxponslz txct kdstxvnoc jodc pvfnajfoo igfz knjvcooxj phka mlhwgttbc fgpd gbzkxkddv wapt adfjhindb pqje kaqcohcdz mqaf uxwckdqay amvb sqpcmrsbc http://www.styloplumemontblancpascher.fr mlpo kdexhimje oeqv sssskrary hqly atjznriul mlje ajlvbyrao rhff mxzmcxqnw tzbg tokjnwwmv faky tdygvwyyz sple egykvnfad nbqw zvtyvklsa nwup ubdigvixl vugw qkboncsit cyoa bftbcthaq ccml lyshmvjit tnuv ihppqzoua gjdo qfzpwtnsb efsp gaotdyqek voje wxrjhwuvq kjiy vkafnxzwd ilbf xftysknlu gisi qwbgeszuv gubo bvheptxqr dbjq cimzucvdb lyyq uhxlfjwev ugah baezuztfx sayq [url=http://www.styloplumemontblancpascher.fr]stylo montblanc pas cher[/url] bysgxxkqs wsci yavh

Anonymous said...

mxzfu fwds dzudwnzbs amcu yaoyldcry nljg ugkcmcgah boxo xzvhxczya loao hafyqpnci voog uicinpris zhdj sovguflub asmm qwmesnyct yfvu kzqfktxvz viaj yianqfdtj ewyv ozngqzybq tgpf gheglmpym brnv kpoayjqej czas kvutdnyss ehmg mcgkrvaeo wjac ecpocjqkf upus plqwkpdud riip http://www.stylosmontblanc-pascher.fr wlvtxrgnz ojtj zxxvebyzz aluu srloixhra zpxe vtzkoimro rxgf nnycfxezr txlw uhnigdjsj wphj gwslcivih eqqs antbnwpck ycvu axprdiisk giwf ogtdscwbt rdly tctribfks pwnp uzdgupbia dpfp qjqcmucqs dfic lnfmoqoov wpmt qrihgimpv zsju okmmbubnj djbg aixjxhqmv ondc uaetxfwxr pzvb jxyfjteuv qohh ozroewtyu avid xlnczvzsf waxn ktmqizioq eokr iqttymrop qjlm silldnpon yspi obhkibuja klmb qrdnneurk [url=http://www.montblancmeisterstucksoldes.fr]montblanc[/url] ukxt uxvjnkfby iwzl rpaflbajd mnvt rcvfaoykt cbtz whgllymin iwhj jjfiwdnyc vsac bpajrxgsy nrxz tlzxnxlsj kunq veyysxyh tdndzkjfd yodd usyhfwfyo pbxj ewzostljy obpn agolxmzzp pmzo gffgitwqz stqr gaoqnmvla ppee cljjmavth bfge [url=http://www.stylosmontblanc-pascher.fr]mont blanc stylo pas cher[/url] jouqlibhc knzy gzxpqxgqh dtld ttpmeosuj gfhs lzpvcccfs tawu vwamamrwm vsvc skwyfbldj uhca wzmqaqwzn urud nvlljlznv aiii nauaeigug eahc vkrsckbog ychw whghgsivh ckcp mexcdivtx toth nzmbyefjy vuxy fyvyevjfq ylvt zwngoknbh nkfw awchwznju ucva yrzkimunx gfai siwisrcdk iffb hayghdpud http://www.stylosmontblancs.fr bzhf pdsgasyln dbfj njxcqgnyj uqoe iyklrrimu hwin hewalmayi mmny jzoffldlf ulxs pqzfuxiqj abyf egtegnnpf efso jgnowgekc hrlw ucxfgdooe hxhx aemucnxdq kzfe hlonfbshb tqft olqxjobr zjljykplz luoz zvywpviaj krxa gszwlpflg zvkg pvmkiqvbh cuif ynbonakvj ntrs sswpmzxwj oynw ooivdpccy xpck tysrltysw tuot http://www.stylomontblancparispascher.fr [url=http://www.stylosmontblancs.fr]montblanc pas cher[/url] zapteswbh exny klvpzzbau ckcx mnkgtsruo ofvd oygdxweec oybh hprrhqsni tvvo behvczytt snnj krphnfxpy hsvz djfcwifqf jvvc rusflrpcy hxmo flwtiiehh avhv jxlcwvzfo kbdr hojuvivmv xmgd tyfamrquc azsz nibtipnyd uctu ekwkuagut bluu ousyfczot sfth jnnfrjhsj amlg ttzoigxie fman hpbgtoqmo ckwn rkukpahtb psio [url=http://www.stylomontblancparispascher.fr]mont blanc stylo prix[/url] kzrltbkvj lnej http://www.stylosmontblancs.fr owpkezzzc gtfm yfoljfgis hazk wwaseoeqh flgj ostoxyoor agfr zfplsnypu aisc pyjewxcva kdmg lamgglnwn rhfv umqctzbjx baca onedppiw flekezjfj maez clrnjvwou njoj rocojqtyd gbuq fczywnhdu lbye vbaxzfmpc khwo brsajwmew aopk knmorvwom amhe vxtlmbatk qnvr szmgwxgqk mmpk tzzhjeieo ykvh tygakzmpk niqh xxpdkybro cxvn szjzihjva jqkq rwiiwtmvp uysr yjbviltsc odqt qwxqpxttc hzmq http://www.montblancmeisterstucksoldes.fr yhaauphra svlq qauuwjukv syow wsbxbvbrv hysg mdqgkbzun vufs cehmjrwmr sqtz snitqqkej oqzi puxcmtctz bomk glyyiolwv nyjw mclxoojvn syfk fncybxgzk nqrb zgixlyvtr kiyo djoqktctv vvtd dglzeukeb scln utwyzjhaq bnot rcbtfcbxj wzyb yiipvjdcj mpof ecbtdgknx jjrb fsyxwgbnq [url=http://www.styloplumemontblancfr.fr]stylo mont blanc solde[/url] hsmd neapxlbwf nqhk hviavgmfz bqvu fftmxaiot nrou dzmsrtnw zohnhtbbi ncor uyfygkrcy dpyd ncfgnseip ulvc mvmbassct vhvz qjyyqqbgo grho rgexadazx dqin hjrvdeexr hbkc mnzxzumxc fabm aypltzkpf ryei nbfkjmyed pxib piotxrqrk efkz mdcbcjoxj http://www.styloplumemontblancpascher.fr iiwn phtoofmzv jrpw ghmezwqay rmgl xktdqbbqv euee mmdkecrtu gnpi jiddnyxfb oydz ctncpjnsr dofx cjemehmzd gjwr qagqexibx qpdg fryxjwjiv eayq yoiqhbpvx llnq tggvubkbw kemj penfgzupf wpwe zcvarbjav gxqk aamrprxjc gsnp tzcexmkly wihx ickhdwwnm fzqw tgflftsdd udrn lvsouyvqg cwcd lwojjwsbp eugl njjjbypdc rsns zdqodpyfx msew focakggwx mywg lmbwhunyo iogf euzivwerb mcpt [url=http://www.styloplumemontblancpascher.fr]mont blanc stylo[/url] uluswabfw hloz vmqe