To commemorate the passing of Rodney King, Jewish Action has a piece this week, titled "Can we all get along" It brings together hacks, functionaries, leaders, and scholars from various Jewish sects and asks them to address the question of achdus, or unity.
Unity:
1. The state or quality of being one; singleness.
2. The state or quality of being in accord; harmony.
Before I get to what the participants said, let me point out that the whole article rest on a false premise: Who says achdus is important? Why pursue it? As it happens, I believe that achdus is neither a valuable goal nor a realistic goal. The world we live in is unavoidably pluralist. We all value different things. We all pursue different goals. He cares about justice; she values mercy. She wants truth; he wants harmony. Many, if not most, of our different goals and values are, in principle, irreconcilable, but many, if not most of those values and goals are also legitimate. This incompatible legitimacy is the True Nature of Things. So how is achdus possible?
It's not. So the answer, then, is not to try to squeeze everyone and everything into the same box, but to recognize and accept the fact that no one box can contain all of us. To do this is not to be a "liberal" but to recognize and accept reality. See, this pluralism I am recommending is not a concession to the failings and shortcomings of those who haven't yet found my truth, but a conclusion that follows naturally from the fact, (yes fact!) that there is no "single formula whereby all the diverse ends of men can be harmoniously realized" (Isaiah Berlin again) To imagine that achdus is possible in a world of incompatible legitimacy is an error. To chase it is to chase a ghost.
SOME OF THE PEOPLE who contributed to the Jewish Action article understand this. Chief Rabbi Saks (who I am mad at) deftly suggests that the unity some of the other contributors prize is not necessary. Instead he counsels love, tolerance and understanding, closing with the wise suggestion that if God can love and forgive so should we. Shlomo Riskin points out the Talmud has room for Rabbis who thought it was OK to eat chicken and milk, and suggests that, in keeping with the old tolerance, perhaps we should lighten up and accept that its authentically Jewish to recognize the authenticity of disagreements. Rabbi Yosie Levine, a third pluralist among the rabbis, calls for conversation (at places like this blog) between members of different groups. The point, he hints, isn't for the conversations to be gentle, lovey-dovey affirming affairs, but vigorous exchanges of ideas. Even when such conversations fail to produce conformity, when conducted in good faith they almost always result in understanding. (And who wants conformity? Conformity weakens communities, rather than strengthening them, whereas understanding has the opposite outcome.)
AND THEN WE GET TO THE AGUDAH CONTINGENT. Really, is there a leader in Jewish life more reprehensible than Chaim Dovid Zweibel? Asked by the OU to comment on Jewish unity, CDZ submits to the OU an article that congratulates the OU on becoming more like the Agudah. For him, achdus is not a misnomer for any of the tolerance, love, forgiveness or conversation advocated by the moderates. No, he wants the real thing: Unity. Conformity. Obeisance. But only to his own way of thinking (which, naturally, he presumes is also God's way of thinking. Happy coincidence!) Zwiebel concludes by saying that "unity" is impossible with anyone who disagrees with him about gays, feminism, or with any leftie scholars who prefer the actual words of Chazal and the Rishonim to myth-making interpretations that have developed more recently. In short, he's a demagogue. And though there is room for demagogues at the table of pluralism, he shouldn't be shy on calling them on their logical and historical errors, or in pointing out their bullying behavior when it occurs.
Search for more information about pluralism at4torah.com
Unity:
1. The state or quality of being one; singleness.
2. The state or quality of being in accord; harmony.
Before I get to what the participants said, let me point out that the whole article rest on a false premise: Who says achdus is important? Why pursue it? As it happens, I believe that achdus is neither a valuable goal nor a realistic goal. The world we live in is unavoidably pluralist. We all value different things. We all pursue different goals. He cares about justice; she values mercy. She wants truth; he wants harmony. Many, if not most, of our different goals and values are, in principle, irreconcilable, but many, if not most of those values and goals are also legitimate. This incompatible legitimacy is the True Nature of Things. So how is achdus possible?
It's not. So the answer, then, is not to try to squeeze everyone and everything into the same box, but to recognize and accept the fact that no one box can contain all of us. To do this is not to be a "liberal" but to recognize and accept reality. See, this pluralism I am recommending is not a concession to the failings and shortcomings of those who haven't yet found my truth, but a conclusion that follows naturally from the fact, (yes fact!) that there is no "single formula whereby all the diverse ends of men can be harmoniously realized" (Isaiah Berlin again) To imagine that achdus is possible in a world of incompatible legitimacy is an error. To chase it is to chase a ghost.
SOME OF THE PEOPLE who contributed to the Jewish Action article understand this. Chief Rabbi Saks (who I am mad at) deftly suggests that the unity some of the other contributors prize is not necessary. Instead he counsels love, tolerance and understanding, closing with the wise suggestion that if God can love and forgive so should we. Shlomo Riskin points out the Talmud has room for Rabbis who thought it was OK to eat chicken and milk, and suggests that, in keeping with the old tolerance, perhaps we should lighten up and accept that its authentically Jewish to recognize the authenticity of disagreements. Rabbi Yosie Levine, a third pluralist among the rabbis, calls for conversation (at places like this blog) between members of different groups. The point, he hints, isn't for the conversations to be gentle, lovey-dovey affirming affairs, but vigorous exchanges of ideas. Even when such conversations fail to produce conformity, when conducted in good faith they almost always result in understanding. (And who wants conformity? Conformity weakens communities, rather than strengthening them, whereas understanding has the opposite outcome.)
AND THEN WE GET TO THE AGUDAH CONTINGENT. Really, is there a leader in Jewish life more reprehensible than Chaim Dovid Zweibel? Asked by the OU to comment on Jewish unity, CDZ submits to the OU an article that congratulates the OU on becoming more like the Agudah. For him, achdus is not a misnomer for any of the tolerance, love, forgiveness or conversation advocated by the moderates. No, he wants the real thing: Unity. Conformity. Obeisance. But only to his own way of thinking (which, naturally, he presumes is also God's way of thinking. Happy coincidence!) Zwiebel concludes by saying that "unity" is impossible with anyone who disagrees with him about gays, feminism, or with any leftie scholars who prefer the actual words of Chazal and the Rishonim to myth-making interpretations that have developed more recently. In short, he's a demagogue. And though there is room for demagogues at the table of pluralism, he shouldn't be shy on calling them on their logical and historical errors, or in pointing out their bullying behavior when it occurs.
Search for more information about pluralism at4torah.com
12 comments:
What is the best approach for you? vpn router use
The program was conceptualized to perfectly fit the needs of the professionals. The existing time frame required for teeth replacement can be shortened manifold this works out to be better from the patient's perspective too., pocketpc cisco vpn client. Your horse should have his own saddle and bridle, adjusted to fit, and kept in good condition. p2p ip blocker
As a small business website owner or as a freelancer, you might be acquainted with precisely how significant it is actually important to have document sharing with your clientele and it actually requires handling in a secure way or else there is actually probability that unacceptable management might on the whole head to the collapse of the system. socks proxy lists
If your user interface has convoluted or complex information, users are likely to get frustrated and abandon it. Nowadays, considering the competition, you can get the best deals and offers like free shipping, free installation, and good packages available for all the requirements, system upgrade, and above all the perfect customer service., anonymous proxy torrent. Whether your goal is to lose 10, even 90 pounds, these weight loss tips will help you get there. vpn dialer open source
This can help you better reach each of the different groups that you need. emule e simili
In many cases, this condition tends to run in families and can last well into teenage years. There are many offensive odor sources, which can not only gross you out, but harm you: one of them is mold., load germany s next top modell. Acai berry has these powerful nutrients in high levels. in demand network
The flash is also of good quality but can result in overexposure. dedicated server cvars. On the other hand, organic weed killers are products that are formed through the joint efforts of farmers and nature enthusiasts. access automation object
So why take such big risks? No need for them to dress up., internet access in remote. The general traditional ceramic raw materials are prepared from clay minerals such as kaolinite, as against the more recent materials which include the usage of aluminum oxide, more commonly known as alumina. objmail server createobject cdo
However, the schemes are equally beneficial for the companies, just as they are for the customers. A scout from a college may possibly makes a research to high school of student to determine whether or not he/she would be a good fit at that college and field. wood privacy metal fence posts. One can find different varieties of food here. People who selfpublished were seen as secondrate and it was very expensive., fox movie network. Because of this, you might want to read comments and reviews about the best cutting boards in the market today. access mde files
Then these items go for recycling., 865gm2 network. Spain cooking tours are truly unique and are cultural trips that vacationers should be looking for! The other important step is to inform the employees about the process and this will aid in motivating them in their day to day operations. access dvd collection. Here are few games which you can really enjoy and have fun:1. x server in linux
In addition, study also found that the proportion of 16yearold to lie is down to 70%. 2000 access cours de support
How can you be sure that the company is one hundred percent true? officeconnect adsl 11g
Post a Comment