A Guest Post By E. Fink
(This post originally appeared on my home blog)
Ami Magazine has an article about orthoprax Jews. I'm not one to complain about tone, so I won't complain. I will just note for the record that the tone of the article is incredibly demeaning to anyone who has ever contemplated the limits of religious belief and the article sounds more like a scathing editorial than a piece of journalism.
In order to understand this blog post it is necessary that you read the Ami Magazine article which is available here: The Impostors Among Us. Come back here when you are done.
The concept of orthopraxy is a simple one. Act like an orthodox Jew but reject some or all of the beliefs of orthodox Judaism. To the author of this article, these people are impostors and the biggest threat to orthodox Judaism that exists.
The biggest problem I have with the article is the approach taken with regard to orthopraxy in general.
In the eyes of the author, one who questions their core beliefs as an Orthodox Jew is literally sick. Either emotionally scarred or intellectually weak describes the types of people who are orthoprax. The assumption is that any sane, intelligent person would obviously conclude that the core beliefs of orthodox Judaism are correct. Further, those beliefs are to believed in their most absolute fundamental form.
However, the article does not, in any way shape or form, actually address the complaints that orthoprax Jews raise against those beliefs. It just assumes that those beliefs are reasonable. To me, this is representative of the flaws that created this problem and the incomptence within the fold in dealing with these issues.
Orthodox Judaism requires certain beliefs. The article, and most orthodox Jews I know, assume that these beliefs are obvious, logical, reasoned conclusions. They possess this belief because they have not been presented any evidence to the contrary. And if they have been presented evidence to the contrary it has been tainted and manipulated by apologists who spin the evidence as non-compelling while only presenting half-truths. Thus, when the soon-to-be-orthopraxer actually is presented with real evidence or questions that poke holes in the once so compelling logic of the orthodox Jewish beliefs, the house of cards comes crashing down.
The primary defense against the destructive nature of this information has been seclusion. This defense (as the article calls it, I wouldn't call it a defense) is not a defense at all. It is avoiding the problems. When someone avoids a problem or skirts an issue the natural reaction is to believe that there is no real answer, there is no solution, the questions are too powerful and the previously held beliefs are not defensible. The next reasonable step is to lose faith in the system.
It is not an illness. It is not the result of emotionally damaged psychosis. It is normal.
If we believe that we possess some sort of truth, then we can't be afraid of other truths. If we are hiding from other truths, it betrays our lack of confidence in our truth. This kind of hypocrisy and closed-mindedness is what causes people to drop their beliefs. Not disease.
The trick is to realize that this is the problem. Once this is established the beginnings of some solutions are not too far out of reach.
The article suggests attending "emunah workshops". There cannot be a worse idea. First of all, emunah is entirely inappropriate a word for these workshops. They are not teaching emunah, faith. They teach quasi-intellectual proofs (which mostly have counter proofs or flaws) in order to prove the divinity of the Torah or the existence of God. These are the very "proofs" that lead to orthopraxy. They wreak of chicanery and feel like mind games. If you ask a question that derails the flow, again, the whole house of cards comes crashing down. If one tries to prove something and the proof fails miserably, one is worse off than if one had not tried to prove it at all. It makes the one trying to do the proving look like a snake oil salesman. No one intelligent is going to buy snake oil.
Instead, I think, the solution should be an expanded, more liberal interpretation of Torah M'Sinai and God. The system needs to give leeway for the varied opinions throughout our tradition that take less of a hard line approach. Don't build that massive house of cards. Try to reintroduce the valid opinions of our great sages that are more compatible with evidence that we now have. That's not to say that those who had opinions that don't comport with what we know today were wrong. They were doing the best they could with the information they had. We should strive to do the same.
Further, there is nothing wrong and there is no reason to attach a stigma to those who have questions. Orthodox Jewish beliefs are not necessarily logical conclusions. Assuming they are and assuming that one who does not reach those same conclusions is a handicapped person, fosters an environment where orthopraxy is sometimes the only choice. But if allowing ourselves to have unresolved questions would be an acceptable place within orthodox Judaism, fewer people would feel the need to jump ship.
The article implies that these impostors must be rooted out and exposed. This is offensive to me. I am sure plenty of great people throughout our storied history have questioned their beliefs. After all, the Rambam wrote a "Guide for the Perplexed". Some people must have been perplexed! I am even more certain that many great people had a parent or two who may have questioned their beliefs. It is also likely that some who questioned, eventually rejected. But I am sure many others either resigned to not knowing or found some satisfaction in the answers they discovered. By exposing, stigmatizing and rooting out anyone who questions their beliefs we are playing with fire. People change their ideas throughout their lives and many who don't can still raise children who can sustain their own beliefs and be successful orthodox Jews. Ruining lives and shunning people who don't think the same way others think is a witch hunt of the worst kind. How can others measure the thoughts of a peer? Thoughts are not measurable by man. Only actions are. (On the importance of action versus thought I recommend Rabbi Slifkin's post: Ominous, Treacherous Infiltrators?)
I believe there is one more area of contemporary orthodox Judaism that significantly contributes to orthopraxy. That is the abundance of mysticism within our community. There are people who are skeptics. It is their nature. These people are not intrigued or impressed with mysticism. If it is not logical or scientific it simply doesn't appeal to them. However, the Judaism of Rambam or R' Hirsch would be very appealing to them. Judaism of 2011 may not. Mysticism requires suspension of disbelief. It is easy to see how one can conflate the unnecessary belief in mysticism with the necessary beliefs of orthodox Judaism. Stop believing (or never believing) in one leads to the other. Making mysticism such an integral part of orthodox Judaism will have a negative affect on those who are skeptics and unnecessarily so. The Judaism of Rambam and R' Hirsch was passionate and deep without many of the things that would turn a skeptic away from Judaism. I believe that part of the problem is that too much suspension of disbelief can turn some of our best and brightest into sacrifices burned at the altar of mysticism.
Finally, we come to the Internet. The article suggests that the Internet is to blame for orthopraxy. While this might be partially true, it does not exonerate the community for pushing these people out. The lack of preparation for discovering new information, the level of misinformation that is taught and the expectation that no one will ever find anything that contradicts the party line are all just as much to blame, if not more, than the actual information that bursts these bubbles.
--------
There are many other ways to approach this article. I believe there are other flaws in the article as well. I have chosen to highlight some of the issues I feel need addressing and may not be addressed by others. As always, I welcome your thoughts and feelings on the article and my musings in the comments.
The article has at least succeeded in providing food for thought. It is an article that has spawned many more articles and conversations. That is a credit to the writer. Hopefully, together, we can work these problems through in a sensible and pleasant manner that will benefit the greater good.
Click here to learn about how you can sell your products on Amazon and receive $75 in free clicks
213 comments:
1 – 200 of 213 Newer› Newest»buy tramadol tramadol hcl muscle relaxer - clorhidrato de tramadol 100mg
buy tramadol online no prescription cod buy tramadol online overnight mastercard - best place buy tramadol
order tramadol online buy tramadol 50mg usa - can you buy tramadol online in the usa
tramadol cheap order tramadol cod saturday delivery - can order ultram online
tramadol online no prescription tramadol hcl 50 mg tab uses - tramadol for dogs with kidney disease
cheap ativan ativan uses alcohol withdrawal - ativan hangover
buy tramadol buy tramadol hydrochloride online - tramadol hcl liquid
tramadol online tramadol 200mg dosage - tramadol hcl and xanax
lorazepam no prescription ativan toxicity - ativan in pregnancy
2mg klonopin klonopin 2012 - klonopin dosage recommendations
buy tramadol online tramadol on drug test - buy tramadol in egypt
buy tramadol cheap no prescription tramadol zolpidem interaction - canada online pharmacy tramadol
klonopin online klonopin withdrawal and dizziness - klonopin dosage panic disorder
lorazepam no prescription buy lorazepam bulk - ativan side effects with alcohol
buy tramadol tramadol constipation - tramadol 100mg for sale
buy tramadol overnight shipping tramadol high blood pressure medication - tramadol 8 per day
clonazepam medication 2 mg klonopin and alcohol - buy klonopin mexico
buy ativan online price for lorazepam 1mg - lorazepam qt prolongation
generic ambien buy 40 mg ambien overdose - ambien cr generic yet
ambien generic ambien drug usage - ambience mall gurgaon phone number
buy tramadol for dogs tramadol no prescription free shipping - tramadol for dogs and side effects
soma online is soma a strong muscle relaxant - buy somatropin forum
where to buy tramadol online tramadol hcl tv 58 - tramadol dosage with paracetamol
buy tramadol without prescriptions legal buy tramadol online - what does tramadol 50 mg do to you
buy tramadol online tramadol junkie - tramadol rash
buy soma bras from soma - buy soma rush frame
buy tramadol buy cheap tramadol online usa - tramadol hcl oral tablet 50 mg
buy tramadol tramadol 50 mg premature ejaculation - tramadol high 100mg
buy ativan online lorazepam ratiopharm 1mg wirkung - ativan blood pressure
buy soma 350mg soma san diego pictures - generic soma wiki
buy ativan expired ativan side effects - what do generic ativan look like
cheap klonopin online generic klonopin online - dying klonopin overdose
buy tramadol with paypal tramadol online health solutions - tramadol side effects high
ambien on line ambien may prompt sleep eating video - ambien side effects weight gain
klonopin pharmacy better high klonopin xanax - klonopin side effects rxlist
buy tramadol online buy tramadol online overnight - tramadol user reviews
buy viagra online buying viagra online guide - order viagra from usa
order ambien online ambien sleep related eating disorder - ambien side effects hair loss
viagra without prescription generic viagra 100mg reviews - viagra buy online no prescription
tramadol online buy generic tramadol online - tramadol hcl 150 mg
buy ambien ambien vs ambien cr side effects - ambien overdose hallucinations
buy cheap ambien buy ambien sleeping pills usa - ambien side effects withdrawal
buy ambien blue circle pill ambien - buy ambien no rx
tramadol online buy tramadol online in florida - tramadol 50 mg canine
generic klonopin klonopin overdose mg - klonopin .5 vs xanax .5
soma medication soma drug user reviews - discount soma no prescription
tramadol online is it illegal to order ultram online - tramadol hcl tylenol
clonazepam drug what's the klonopin high like - klonopin for generalized anxiety disorder
buying ambien online define ambien medication - ambien side effects migraine
buy viagra no prescription viagra online 100mg - viagra dosage time
buy viagra los angeles viagra ebay - buy viagra eu
soma online soma 250 high - buy soma safely online
ambien zolpidem generic ambien ndc - side effects of zolpidem tartrate 10 mg tablet
how to order viagra can i purchase viagra online - viagra canada pharmacy online
buy viagra generic viagra levitra cialis - buy viagra australia
buy tramadol online tramadol online no prescription needed - has anyone ordered tramadol online
cheap generic soma buy soma online canadian pharmacy - pass drug test soma
buy viagra online no rx buy viagra canadian pharmacy - viagra online sales
can you buy viagra online buy brand viagra online - viagra 50mg reviews
buy tramadol online with mastercard zydol tramadol overdose - where can i buy tramadol over the counter in the us
buy viagra now buy cheap viagra pills online - viagra 2 chainz hulk
cialis pills generic cialis ebay - buy cialis online in nz
viagra drug buy viagra canada online - cheap viagra cialis levitra
buy viagra online cheap purchase viagra delhi - cheapest order pharmacy viagra
cialis online cialis 5mg side effects - best price cialis 5 mg
order viagra with mastercard viagra online from uk - how to purchase viagra in canada
cheap propecia will generic propecia available us - much does propecia cost cvs
tramadol online tramadol dose get high - buy cheap tramadol usa
buy propecia online buy propecia 1 mg online - propecia side effects cnn
buy tramadol cheap buy tramadol 50mg net - tramadol 50 mg looks like
order propecia online buy generic propecia us - cheapest place buy propecia
buy tramadol uk tramadol 150 mg dose - tramadol 50mg max dosage
buy propecia online propecia gay - generic propecia safety
how to order viagra viagra light switch cover - buy viagra gold
buy cialis prescription online generic cialis mjy.blogspot.com - cialis online authentic
retin a cream how to buy retin a online - retin a micro eczema
generic atomoxetine strattera weight loss children - much does generic strattera cost
buy tramadol online tramadol jaw clenching - tramadol on drug test
finasteride hair loss generic propecia online no prescription - propecia 2 months
buy tramadol online reviews buy tramadol ireland - online apotheke holland tramadol
buy tramadol tramadol online overnight saturday delivery - tramadol hcl er 300
buy tramadol buy tramadol online no prescription next day delivery - tramadol ultram same thing
best buy tramadol tramadol hcl 50 mg cost - tramadol 50mg tablets dogs
buy tramadol online cod tramadol 50mg tablets cost - order generic tramadol
tramadol online tramadol no prescription cheap - tramadol hcl 50mg tab dosage
buy tramadol online without a prescription tramadol hcl 50 mg dogs - tramadol high blood pressure medication
tramadol 50 best place buy tramadol online reviews - tramadol hcl 50 mg strong
buy tramadol tramadol hcl premature ejaculation - tramadol 50mg dosage dogs
order propecia online generic propecia in 2012 - propecia results pics
retin a buy buy retin a online amazon - retin-a gel buy
tramadol no prescription buy tramadol online forum - buy tramadol cod overnight
buy tramadol cash on delivery tramadol for dogs liver - tramadol dosage limits
order tramadol online tramadol xl dosage - buy tramadol cheap no prescription
retin a skin retin a gel over the counter - retin-a gel tretinoin
tramadol 50mg order tramadol online legally - tramadol vs vicodin
buy retin-a retin a cream benefits - buy retin a tretinoin
propecia online pharmacy propecia 20 years old - is a generic version of propecia available
buy retin-a online retin a cream for wrinkles - retin a cream initial breakout
buy tramadol without prescriptions tramadol for dogs pet meds - buy tramadol online from usa
buy propecia online propecia results 20 year old - propecia kaufen
buy tramadol uk can order tramadol online - buy tramadol overnight delivery no prescription
buy retin-a online buy retin a online in usa - retin a help acne scars
tramadol online no prescription buy cheap tramadol online cod - dangers tramadol addiction
discount viagra buy viagra online los angeles - order viagra online overnight delivery
generic viagra buy viagra pay with paypal - buy-viagra-online-50mg
tramadol online tramadol 50 mg compared - tramadol hcl dogs dosage
tramadol 50mg tramadol hcl canine - can take 100mg tramadol one time
buy viagra cheap viagra online tesco - best viagra online reviews
buy cialis cheap cialis overnight delivery - cialis personal reviews
generic cialis generic cialis online pharmacy - cheap cialis europe
buy cialis buy generic cialis online australia - cialis men
discount viagra viagra long term side effects - topical viagra for women
buy tramadol tramadol hcl powder - buy cheap tramadol uk
buy cialis cialis 5 mg daily review - cialis 60 mg
cheap viagra buy viagra online from australia - generic viagra online cheap
buy tramadol no prescription ultram online without rx - tramadol dosage 10 lb dog
buy cialis no prescription order cialis with no prescription - buy viagra cialis online
viagra cost generic viagra without prescriptions - buying viagra online guide
viagra no prescription buy viagra online best sites - generic viagra online canadian pharmacy
generic cialis generic cialis warning - cialis online sydney
viagra for sale generic viagra soft tabs - buy viagra via paypal
generic cialis buy+cialis+online+without+prescription+in+canada - generic cialis 10mg
order viagra viagra buy online germany - buy real viagra online
buy viagra online mail order viagra us - generic viagra cialis or levitra online
cheapest cialis buy cialis online canada pharmacy - viagra or cialis online
cheap cialis generic cialis ranbaxy - cialis que es
generic cialis cialis price rite aid - cialis online thailand
buy cialis cialis online germany - reviews viagra vs cialis vs levitra
buy cialis cialis online uk - buy cialis online generic
generic cialis generic cialis soft tabs - buy cialis online no prescription
buy cialis online cheap cialis 20mg - generic cialis rx
cheapest cialis order cheap cialis online - generic cialis quality
cialis cost get prescription cialis online - cialis overdose
buy cialis is cheap cialis safe - generic cialis soft tabs
buy somas soma 5513 dan - soma drug test urine
viagra online where can i find really cheap viagra - allintitle viagra 6 free samples
viagra online buy real viagra - buy generic viagra us
viagra online viagra what dosage is recommended - viagra online forum
buy viagra cheap to buy viagra online us - buy viagra tesco pharmacy
soma online pharmacy makes generic soma - cheap restaurants soma san francisco
soma carisoprodol soma drug reactions - what does generic soma look like
soma for sale soma pills get you high - motels near soma san diego
soma pharmacy cheap holidays soma bay - soma pharmacy no prescription
buy soma 350mg soma online game - soma medication buy online
soma cost buy soma watson brand online - buy soma usa
soma no prescription soma drug type - soma san diego news
buy soma buy soma online mastercard - will soma show up benzo drug test
buy soma 350mg buy soma europe - buy soma online ship texas
soma online soma online next day delivery - buy some plant
buy soma soma san diego jobs - buy soma online from usa
buy soma online buy soma saturday delivery - generic soma description
buy soma buy soma from usa - soma discount code 2012
buy cialis online order cialis australia - where to order cialis us
cialis online no prescription cialis onset of action - cialis online andorra
buy retin a retin a micro miracle - retin a micro gel aging
buy soma online soma costa mesa - buy soma chocolate
best buy tramadol 001webs com buy tramadol online - tramadol hcl 50mg buy
tramadol 50mg buy tramadol online with cod - tramadol online tennessee
buy retin-a online retin-a micro tretinoin gel microsphere .1 - retin a micro side effects
buy tramadol in florida purchase tramadol online - tramadol online fedex
retin a gel retin a cream 0.025 - retin a cream for acne marks
cheap tramadol buy tramadol legit - tramadol jwh 018
generic tramadol buy tramadol usa - is it legal to order tramadol over the internet
buy tramadol buy tramadol overnight delivery - buy tramadol online mastercard
buy retin a retin a gel purchase - retin a micro not covered by insurance
cheap tramadol tramadol extended release - buy tramadol with paypal
cheap tramadol online tramadol for dogs drug interactions - can you buy tramadol online in usa
cheap tramadol can order ultram online - tramadol hcl paracetamol tablets
buy retin-a retin a tretinoin cream - retin a 0.1 cream 40 grams
tramadol online tramadol addictive properties - tramadol ingredients acetaminophen
tramadol online pharmacy can you buy tramadol over counter us - pet meds tramadol no prescription
buy tramadol online can you buy tramadol over the counter usa - tramadol withdrawal one week
buy retin-a without prescription retin a micro coupon - retin a cream expired
cheap tramadol order tramadol for dogs - buy ultram online canada
where to buy tramadol tramadol hcl webmd - tramadol online cod
buy tramadol tramadol 50mg street value - purchase tramadol 50mg
cheap tramadol buy tramadol with american express - tramadol hcl nausea
tadalafil online cialis price at walmart - cialis joint pain
buy cialis no prescription buy cialis reviews - generic cialis buy us
buy tramadol online cheap buy tramadol using mastercard - tramadol normal dosage
buy discount tramadol buy tramadol online with a cod - tramadol dosage pain dogs
buy tramadol tramadol for dogs half life - buy tramadol online mastercard
buy tramadol tramadol 50mg side effects - purchase tramadol dogs
buy tramadol online kandungan tramadol hcl - tramadol hcl er 150 mg
cheap tramadol buy tramadol online in australia - tramadol dosage veterinary medicine
generic xanax xanax 1 mg apteka - long term side effects xanax xr
cheap generic xanax xanax youtube - xanax questions
generic tramadol countries can you buy tramadol over counter - tramadol high 50mg
generic xanax 1mg xanax night - pictures generic 2mg xanax
buy tramadol tramadol for dogs nausea - tramadol overdose
tramadol overnight shipping tramadol gotas - tramadol 50 mg much
xanax online how long does a xanax high last - xanax dosage intervals
alprazolam xanax bars yellow mg - xanax side effects in women
tramadol online order tramadol for dog - where to buy tramadol online legal
where can i buy xanax online what are the different kinds of xanax pills - xanax drug dosage
buy tramadol online order tramadol online - tramadol hcl obat
cialis pharmacy cialis prices usa - buy brand cialis online
cialis online buy cialis 10mg - generic cialis any good
cialis online pharmacy cialis daily sample - cialis online cheapest
xanax online xanax withdrawal symptoms tremors - xanax online pharmacy overnight
Post a Comment