Thursday, September 01, 2005

Wieseltier on Gaza: Scorching, Brilliant

Leon Wieseltier, literary editor of The New Republic, and a graduate of the Yeshiva of Flatbush, has written a very important article on Gaza. The opening salvo:
Even faced with the idea of Greater Palestine, it is impossible not to rejoice in the defeat of the idea of Greater Israel. It was always a foul idea, morally and strategically. It promoted the immediate ecstasy of the few above the eventual safety of the many; it introduced the toxins of messianism and mysticism into the politics of a great modern democracy; it preferred chosenness to human rights; it subordinated laws to visions, and the Jewish state to the Jewish millennium; it worshiped soil in a primitive, almost un-Jewish way. The settlers of the West Bank and Gaza are not a Jewish vanguard, they are a Jewish sect; and in their insistence that the destiny of their state and their society should be held hostage to the fulfillment of their metaphysical and historical conceptions, they have always displayed a sectarian self-love. [... finish the article]
Another excerpt:
For this reason, when I behold the photographs of the settlers in Gaza uprooted by Israeli soldiers, empathy almost completely deserts me. I seem to have a heart of stone, and I am not entirely embarrassed by it. More precisely, I regard the eviction of the settlers as the appropriate reward for their own hearts of stone. For many other Jews gave their lives and their limbs so that these Jews could grow their holy tomatoes and study their holy texts in this desert. In order to satisfy their individual and collective aspirations, the Israeli civilians who lived in Gaza required the sacrifice of Israeli soldiers in Gaza. In the years of Jewish settlement in Gaza, 230 Israelis were killed there. A substantial number of them were soldiers. Why is the life of a Jew in a uniform worth less than the life of a Jew in a greenhouse? That is stone-heartedness. And yet one hears mainly about the sacrifices of the settlers. Surely the same stirring revival of Zionist agronomy could have been accomplished in the equally arid zones a few miles to the north or the east, in a place called Israel. [... finish the article]
I've sent this article, by email, to a handful of right-leaning Jewish bloggers, bloggers I respect, bloggers who almost always have something new and thoughtful to say. As you'll see, Weiseltier's article makes several points about Gaza that I've been struggling (for lack of talent) to present myself. I'm curious to hear what the "other side" thinks when the argument is made properly and by someone with Weiseltier's skill.

I am really looking forward to reading the reactions of those right-leaning bloggers to Weiseltier's article. I hope they respond.