A Guest Post By E. Fink
There are 4 prominent versions going around the web right now.
Rabbi Shafran Version 1: God punished the people of Haiti because of evil speech.
Rabbi Shafran Version 2: We don't know why God punished the people of Haiti but the lesson is that we should learn is not to speak evil speech.
Rabbi Levin: The earthquake and Tsunami and 9/11 happened because of Gays in the military.
Rabbi Feldman: We can't know why the earthquake happened, but it happened for "a reason".
What has been missing from this is a more rational approach predicated on the teachings of Rav Yaakov Weinberg Ztz"l Rosh Yeshiva of Ner Yisrael.
Let's start with a hypothetical question.
Gerald is driving through the desert. He gets lost and runs out of fuel. He gets out of the car to start walking to find a gas station. He wanders for a little while. Eventually he runs out of water. He dehydrates and eventually dies in the desert.
Why did he die?
That is easy. He died because he ran out of water in a desert. The rules of nature that God created and recreates every moment dictate that when a man has no water in a desert he will dehydrate and probably die shortly thereafter. God does not bend or adjust the rules of nature to save him. Nor should God bend the rules of nature. The relationship God has with the world is that of a hidden God. God hides behind the mask of nature and does not show Himself.
There is a fault line the lies beneath Port Au Prince. It was suggested by geologists in late 2008 that there could be a severe earthquake in Haiti as a result of this fault line. In January 2010 the plates along the fault line shifted. A massive earthquake ensued. Thousands of people died and many more were injured.
Why did they die?
That is also easy. They died because there was an earthquake. The rules of nature that God created and recreates at every moment dictate that when tectonic plates shift it can cause a massive earthquake. God does not bend or adjust the rules of nature to stop the earthquake. Nor should God bend the rules of nature. The relationship God has with the world is that of a hidden God. God hides behind the mask of nature and does not show Himself.
What about the stories in Chumash and Tanach that report miracles to save individuals or groups of people?
Once in a while God does bend the rules of nature. This is rare and only happens in extreme circumstances. We call this a miracle. It is really a misnomer because everything is a miracle. Nature is a miracle just as much as the supernatural. But we only recognize or would recognize the supernatural miraculous. Miracles can happen, but we don't rely on miracles nor do we expect miracles as part of the usual system and order of the universe. The universe follows the rules of nature that God created and recreates every moment.
What about the words of Chazal that blame natural disasters on sin?
I can't answer with certainty but there are a few options:
- For lack of scientific information they did not realize that earthquakes or other phenomena were "natural" and supposed they were supernatural events thus requiring a Divine reason.
- They were referring to a place and time where God did intervene on a constant basis.
- They were speaking polemically and urging Klal Yisrael to improve their ways and as a way of admonishing them they used exegesis to connect disaster with sin.
- They were misquoted or quoted out of context.
Then there is the Rambam. In hilchos Taanis, the Rambam states that when harm befalls the tzibur it incumbent upon klal yisrael to do teshuva and attribute the suffering the "way of the world" rather the bad things that happened were because of their evil sins.
This has been misquoted and misapplied in many instances. The Rambam is talking about a tragedy that happens to the tzibur. The tzibur refers to the Jewish community. So a harm among the a specific Jewish community is the time that we must attribute the harm to OUR sins.
What Rabbis Shafran Version 1, Feldman and Levin are doing is trying to use this Rambam in an instance of a tragedy that befell ANOTHER group of people. The earthquake was not a disaster that happened to the Jewish tzibur. It happened to another tzibur. Thus, the Rambam does not apply.
When would the Rambam apply? At most a tragedy that targets the tzibur. Most strictly constructed it would be when a harm is specific to the Jewish people.
So what are we supposed to do when tragedy strikes? When there is a Hurricane like Katrina, a Tsunami like there was in Southeast Asia or Earthquake like in Haiti?
We work on our compassion. We work on our empathy. We help as much as we can. We remember that life is fleeting and it can all end in a moment. We try to reenergize our relationships. We improve in our avodas Hashem. We find a way to use the tragedy to inspire us. It is personal.
For anyone to assume they know why this tragedy happened fails on three counts.
1) It did not happen to us. It happened to someone else. Do we believe in a God who punishes another party for OUR sins?
2) Maybe it did not happen for a reason? If it was natural then how are you going to apply some sin as the cause for nature? Do you blame sin every time a lion eats a gazelle in the African plain? How about when an innocent bystander is killed by a drunk driver? Did the bystander "deserve it"?
3) Even if it did happen for a reason, who are you to tell me why it happened? You think YOU know? Your puny little brain can figure out why God acts in the way He does? You know all the factors that go into "causing a natural disaster"? At best it is presumptuous at worst it is extreme arrogance bordering on apikorsus.
For anyone to guess why this happened fails on another count.
Nevuah (prophecy) ended thousands of years ago. A Navi (prophet) was like a spiritual doctor, one was able to see a Navi and ask why bad things were happening to you and the Navi could tell you why. The Navi was connected to God. That is over. It ended a long time ago. I am suspect of anyone claiming to know what God is "thinking" because they have no way of knowing.
Trying to pretend like we know why the earthquake happened, even if we assume it happened for a reason, is wrong.
But at least Rabbi Shafran Version 2 and Rabbi Feldman are telling US to improve our lives in the wake of the tragedy.
Only one goofball has the gall to tell OTHER people how to act in response to the tragedy. Only Levin has the audacity to tell the Government of the USA that it's "their fault" this happened. Only Levin completely abrogates himself and places the blame on something that is external to him and his group.
It is akin to telling a grieving mother that her son who was run over by a car was run over because the lady across the street had an affair. Ridiculous. Irresponsible. Self-righteous. Idiotic. Moronic. (Help me out here… I am sure there are more words…)
In summary, there are varying levels of what I believe to be errors in the wake of this tragedy. The least egregious is trying to figure what the precise message of the earthquake is. The most egregious is telling a 3rd party that they caused the tragedy of another.
My view, as I stated just after the earthquake, and the view of my Rebbeim is that the tragedy was a natural disaster. There was no malicious intent or direct message being sent to the people of Haiti or anyone else for that matter. However, it is useful for us to use the incident as inspiration to improve our lives and live each moment we are fortunate to be alive as a way of making the world a better place.
Postscript: A worthwhile read is Rabbi Dov Kramer's approach which is very similar to what is written here just comes from a different direction.
Search for more information about theodicy at 4torah.com.
Going to Israel?
Now get 2 phones for the price of 1 (and free calls too) with Talk'n'Save.
buy valium cheap valium sale online - valium drug reactions
ReplyDeletediazepam online diazepam basic drug - diazepam 10mg bula
ReplyDeleteativan pills ativan vs xanax for flight anxiety - ativan 3mg
ReplyDeletexanax depression buy 2mg xanax bars online - xanax side effects twitching
ReplyDeletediazepam 10 mg buy diazepam online australia - buy diazepam 10mg online usa
ReplyDeleteorder lorazepam ativan dosage in seizure - ativan beer
ReplyDeleteorder soma cheap soma online no prescription - generic soma india
ReplyDeletesoma muscle soma 350mg online - order soma cod
ReplyDeletebuy soma carisoprodol 350mg high - soma drug ancient
ReplyDeletebuy valium online valium cold medication - valium pills info
ReplyDeletebuy generic soma carisoprodol 31 - watson carisoprodol 350 mg
ReplyDeleteambien pills ambien side effects weakness - ambien makes me feel good
ReplyDeletegeneric soma online where to buy somatropin - carisoprodol glaucoma
ReplyDeleteorder tramadol overnight buy tramadol - buy tramadol pet
ReplyDeleteativan pharmacy ativan withdrawal onset - ativan withdrawal chills
ReplyDeletetramadol generic buy tramadol online saturday delivery - legal purchase tramadol online
ReplyDeletebuy tramadol online without a prescription order tramadol free shipping - tramadol for dogs with arthritis
ReplyDeletebuy tramadol buy tramadol hcl - buy tramadol us
ReplyDeletebuy tramadol cheap online tramadol hcl 50mg tv 58 - buy tramadol hydrochloride online
ReplyDeletebuy tramadol ultram buy tramadol online overnight shipping - ultram online no prescription
ReplyDeletebuy klonopin online klonopin and alcohol bluelight - what is klonopin high
ReplyDeletebuy tramadol uk tramadol lethal dose - tramadol hcl half life
ReplyDeleteorder ativan online ativan dosage before surgery - addiction xanax ativan
ReplyDeletebuy zolpidem online dosage levels of ambien - highest dosage ambien cr
ReplyDeleteclonazepam mg buy klonopin online overnight - generic for klonopin
ReplyDeletesoma buy soma san diego twitter - order soma without rx
ReplyDeletebuy tramadol tablets buy tramadol without a script - tramadol dosage mayo clinic
ReplyDeletezolpidem without prescription ambien cr 12.5 coupon - ambien side effects double vision
ReplyDeletebuy ambien online ambien sales 2010 - buy ambien hong kong
ReplyDeletebuy tramadol tramadol 50 mg pain killer - tramadol hcl 37.5-3 tab myla
ReplyDeletebuy tramadol with cod tramadol hcl overdose amount - buy tramadol online cheap
ReplyDeletebuy lorazepam online ativan 75 mg - ativan dosage time
ReplyDeletegeneric ambien online ambien walrus urban dictionary - ambience mall gurgaon 5d
ReplyDeletebuy tramadol mexico buy tramadol online missouri - tramadol 50 mg active ingredients
ReplyDeletebuy soma online soma medication dosage - soma muscle relaxers information
ReplyDeletebuy ambien online ambien side effects weight gain - ambience mall gurgaon movies
ReplyDeletebuy tramadol ultram buy tramadol no prescription free shipping - buy tramadol online no prescription overnight
ReplyDeletebuy soma online generic soma 250 - buy cheap generic soma
ReplyDeletecan you buy ambien online ambien cr youtube - ambience mall gurgaon shuttle service timings
ReplyDeletebuy klonopin online buy clonazepam 2mg - lowest dosage klonopin
ReplyDeletegeneric ambien buy xanax ambien online - ambien side effects next day
ReplyDeletebuy generic tramadol buy tramadol hcl 50 mg - tramadol dosage headaches
ReplyDeletesoma online soma muscle relaxer get you high - cheapest soma online
ReplyDeletegeneric ambien i took 3 10 mg ambien - more than 10 mg ambien
ReplyDeletegeneric tramadol online купить tramadol online - buy tramadol no prescription canada
ReplyDeletewhere to buy tramadol buy tramadol from india - tramadol dosage labrador retriever
ReplyDeletelorazepam without prescription buy lorazepam online - 6 mg ativan too much
ReplyDeletesoma online stores carry soma bras - buy soma cod
ReplyDeletebuy klonopin online cheap klonopin 9 mg - klonopin high duration
ReplyDeletesoma online soma yoga ithaca - mission soma 92101
ReplyDeleteambien order ambien withdrawal insomnia - ambien lithium drug interactions
ReplyDeletecheap ambien no prescription ambien side effects short term memory loss - ambien half life elderly
ReplyDeleteklonopin pills buy clonazepam canada - klonopin 33
ReplyDeletebuy viagra online usa does viagra work right away - viagra dosage experience
ReplyDeleteorder tramadol online cod tramadol dosage erowid - tramadol high
ReplyDeletebuy ambien online ambien and pregnancy 2010 - ambien side effects seizures
ReplyDeleteviagra online viagra where to buy in shop - viagra and nitroglycerin
ReplyDeletebuy cheap viagra viagra online canada mastercard - cheap viagra from canada online
ReplyDeleteambien ambien cr price canada - ambien cr take
ReplyDeletegeneric ambien ambien sleep on airplane - buy ambien 10mg
ReplyDeletebuy klonopin online klonopin for performance anxiety - buy klonopin online no prescription
ReplyDeletebuy viagra 100mg can you buy viagra vietnam - buy viagra in las vegas
ReplyDeletegeneric ambien ambien benadryl - ambien cr there generic
ReplyDeletebuy tramadol cheap where can i buy real tramadol - tramadol dosage equivalent
ReplyDeletecheap ambien ambien 10 mg image - ambien narcotic drug
ReplyDeleteorder viagra from canada is buying generic viagra online safe - buy viagra online india
ReplyDeleteklonopin drug klonopin causing anxiety - 2mg klonopin equal
ReplyDeletebuy viagra viagra online xl - buy mexican viagra online
ReplyDeletewhere to buy tramadol tramadol bargain - tramadol 93 149
ReplyDeletebuy soma online soma 350 mg overdose - soma 350mg
ReplyDeletebuy viagra cheap purchase viagra online - generic viagra online free prescription
ReplyDeletebuy viagra online viagra for women gel - generic viagra forum
ReplyDeleteorder viagra now buy viagra online uk next day delivery - generic viagra online pharmacy review
ReplyDeletebuy viagra next day delivery illegal buy viagra online canada - highest safe dosage viagra
ReplyDeletecialis online отзывы о cialis - buy cialis online in new zealand
ReplyDeletebuy tramadol online mastercard overnight buy tramadol online prescription - tramadol hcl ultram 50 mg
ReplyDeleteonline soma buy soma from usa - soma mini velo
ReplyDeletebuy viagra for women buy generic viagra online paypal - pfizer viagra dosage
ReplyDeleteviagra online viagra online order no prescription - viagra canadian pharmacy no prescription
ReplyDeletebuy soma online buy soma online ship florida - soma pills for sale
ReplyDeletetramadol online tramadol overdose how long - tramadol for dogs how often
ReplyDeletebuy tramadol free shipping tramadol euphoria dose - order tramadol online cod
ReplyDeleteviagra online pharmacy cheap viagra reviews - generic viagra cialis or levitra online
ReplyDeleteorder sildenafil buy viagra online uk cheap - can i buy viagra online yahoo answers
ReplyDeletebuy propecia online generic propecia lowest price - cheap propecia in the uk
ReplyDeletebuy viagra real viagra online canadian pharmacy - buy viagra los angeles
ReplyDeleteviagra online galaxy 959 viagra board - buy 200 mg viagra
ReplyDeletediscount viagra buy viagra online yahoo answers - where to buy generic viagra in uk
ReplyDeletetramadol generic tramadol mg - buy tramadol usa next day delivery
ReplyDeletegeneric finasteride propecia side effects percentage - propecia visual results
ReplyDeletebuy tramadol online with mastercard tramadol hcl 50mg buy - buy tramadol health solutions network
ReplyDeleteviagra online buy viagra pfizer online no prescription - where can you buy viagra online using paypal
ReplyDeletebuy cialis cheap online secure tabs online cialis 20 mg - cialis daily pill
ReplyDeletehow to order viagra how to buy viagra no prescription - cheap viagra in the usa
ReplyDeletebuy tramadol cod tramadol for dogs can people take it - tramadol hcl zoloft
ReplyDeletebuy viagra generic viagra online canada no prescription - viagra 30 year old
ReplyDeletebuy propecia online propecia cost yahoo - cheap propecia london
ReplyDeletebuy tramadol online tramadol experiences - tramadol for dogs side effects panting
ReplyDeletebuy tramadol online best website buy tramadol - tramadol hcl 100mg er
ReplyDeletebuy tramadol clonazepam tramadol high - buy tramadol online safe
ReplyDeletegeneric strattera strattera side effects dizziness - strattera atomoxetine reviews
ReplyDeleteorder propecia online year supply propecia cost - buy cheap propecia online no prescription
ReplyDeletebuy tramadol order tramadol 50mg - high dose of tramadol
ReplyDeletecheapest propecia buy generic propecia usa - buy propecia 1mg or 5mg
ReplyDeletecheap tramadol tramadol dosage headaches - tramadol overnight shipping
ReplyDeletetramadol online pharmacy tramadol 50mg good high - tramadol high bluelight
ReplyDeletebuy propecia online buy propecia ebay - can see results propecia
ReplyDeletebuy tramadol buy tramadol online no rx - tramadol 50mg max dosage
ReplyDeletebuy tramadol online no prescription tramadol hcl 650 - tramadol legal to buy online
ReplyDeletecheap strattera strattera dosage child - buy strattera online usa
ReplyDeletetramadol online buy tramadol online cheap - can i buy tramadol online legally
ReplyDeletebuy tramadol online no prescription cod tramadol cod - tramadol liver
ReplyDeletetramadol 50 mg tramadol 7171 - tramadol 50 mg erowid
ReplyDeletediscount propecia where to buy propecia and rogaine - propecia testimonials
ReplyDeletebuy retin-a online retin a gel or cream - retin a micro side effects
ReplyDeleteretin a cream buy retin a in usa - retin a micro red face
ReplyDeletebuy propecia online generic propecia finasteride reviews - propecia use in women
ReplyDeletebuy propecia online propecia nbc - propecia 0.25mg effective
ReplyDeletebuy tramadol hcl buy tramadol usa pharmacy - buy tramadol online no prescription
ReplyDeleteviagra sildenafil buy viagra online in the us - best way purchase viagra
ReplyDeleteviagra online buy 1 viagra - buy real viagra online us
ReplyDeletecheap viagra buy viagra online legit - where to buy viagra online forum
ReplyDeletegeneric cialis online cialis low blood pressure - cialis online from us pharmacy
ReplyDeletegeneric viagra buy non generic viagra - cheap female viagra online
ReplyDeleteviagra 50mg buy viagra legally online us - viagra 7 11
ReplyDeletecheap viagra buy genuine viagra us - viagra buy online us
ReplyDeletegeneric cialis online cialis online buy - cialis daily how long does it take to work
ReplyDeletetadalafil no prescription cialis 10 mg daily - generic cialis jelly
ReplyDeletebuy tramadol tramadol 50 mg equivalent - tramadol online
ReplyDeletecheap viagra viagra dosage 25 mg - buy viagra online with prescription
ReplyDeletebuy sildenafil how to purchase viagra in us - viagra jello shots
ReplyDeletegeneric cialis buy cialis online fast shipping generic - online apotheke cialis 20mg
ReplyDeleteviagra online without prescription generic viagra 100mg - buy generic viagra american express
ReplyDeletegeneric viagra viagra online free trial - viagra for women online
ReplyDeletegeneric viagra viagra sale online pharmacy - buy cheap viagra and cialis
ReplyDeleteviagra online pharmacy viagra discount - viagra online without prescription
ReplyDeletehow to buy cialis buy cialis in ireland - cialis 5mg user reviews
ReplyDeletecheapest cialis where to buy cialis online in uk - cialis online australia
ReplyDeletebuy generic cialis online no prescription buy cialis online reviews - cialis samples
ReplyDeletebuy viagra order viagra online south africa - generic viagra online
ReplyDeleteviagra 50mg cheap viagra with prescription - secure tabs online viagra 100mg
ReplyDeletecialis online canada cheap cialis prices canada - can i buy cialis over the counter in the uk
ReplyDeletecheap cialis reviews for online cialis - buy cialis today
ReplyDeletecialis online pharmacy cialis 10 mg reviews - cialis warnings
ReplyDeletecialis price generic cialis line - cialis online bestellen erfahrungen
ReplyDeletecialis online pharmacy cialis online free trial - buy cialis online malaysia
ReplyDeletecialis pharmacy cialis online mexico - best quality generic cialis
ReplyDeletebuy cialis reviews of generic cialis - generic cialis good
ReplyDeletebuy cialis order generic cialis online - generic cialis and viagra
ReplyDeletebuy tramadol online tramadol overdose stories - buy tramadol online no prescription mastercard
ReplyDeletesoma drug buy soma online no prescription - soma pills get you high
ReplyDeletecheapest soma soma san diego nevershoutnever - soma skeletal muscle relaxant
ReplyDeletesoma muscle relaxant images of generic soma - buy soma online credit card
ReplyDeletebuy soma soma muscle relaxer erowid - generic of soma
ReplyDeletebuy soma soma 365 studio - soma discount code 2011
ReplyDeletesoma online buy cheap hgh - somatropin - buy hgh - somatropin online
ReplyDeletesoma medication generic soma no prescription - soma san diego chiodos
ReplyDeletebuy retin-a online retin-a micro tretinoin gel 0.1 - retin-a gel in pregnancy
ReplyDeletebuy tramadol cod fedex tramadol hcl drug class - tramadol vs percocet
ReplyDeletebuy cialis online buy 36 hour cialis online - cialis customer reviews
ReplyDeleteorder tramadol buy generic tramadol no prescription - buy tramadol no prescription canada
ReplyDeletetramadol 50mg tramadol hcl 37.5 mg - buy tramadol 50mg online
ReplyDeletebuy tramadol online cod overnight recovering tramadol addiction - tramadol hcl what does it do
ReplyDeletediscount retin-a buy retin a gel 0.025 - buy retin usa
ReplyDeletediscount retin-a where to buy retin a cream in australia - retin-a oily skin
ReplyDeleteorder tramadol online without prescription can you buy tramadol over the counter in usa - tramadol 50 mg tablets side effects
ReplyDeletebest buy tramadol tramadol 50mg buzz - tramadol pain killer
ReplyDeleteretin a online where to buy retin a cream in usa - retin a micro dark spots on skin
ReplyDeletebuy tramadol online kind drug tramadol 50mg - tramadol narcotic
ReplyDeletecheap retin-a retin-a walgreens - retin a micro gel for acne scars
ReplyDeletetramadol 50 buy tramadol 100 - where to buy tramadol online safely
ReplyDeletebuy tramadol with mastercard tramadol jaundice - buy-tramadol.biz
ReplyDeletetramadol 50 mg buy tramadol cod - tramadol purchase no prescription
ReplyDeletebuy tramadol with cod buy tramadol online cash delivery - tramadol 50 mg take
ReplyDeletebuy tramadol 180 buy tramadol uk - tramadol online reliable
ReplyDeletebuy tramadol no rx order tramadol from usa - tramadol overdose dose
ReplyDeletebuy tramadol no prescription overnight tramadol 50mg street price - order tramadol online reviews
ReplyDeletebuy tramadol saturday delivery order tramadol online saturday delivery - best place buy tramadol online reviews
ReplyDeletecheap tramadol tramadol dangers - buy tramadol online prescription
ReplyDeletebuy tramadol 100mg online tramadol 100mg buy - legal buy tramadol online
ReplyDeletewhere to buy tramadol online is it legal to order tramadol over the internet - buy tramadol online reviews
ReplyDeletebuy tramadol online without a prescription buy tramadol montreal - cheap tramadol online cod
ReplyDeletetramadol 100mg tramadol toothache - tramadol no prescription usa
ReplyDeletecarisoprodol online effects of carisoprodol 350 mg - carisoprodol 350 mg efectos secundarios
ReplyDeletetramadol online buy tramadol buy cod - order tramadol online no rx
ReplyDeletebuy cialis viagra generic cialis 60 mg - cialis online from usa
ReplyDeletebuy klonopin online klonopin overdose antidote - klonopin names
ReplyDeletebuy klonopin online starting dose of klonopin for anxiety - klonopin wafers roche
ReplyDeletehttp://landvoicelearning.com/#63987 tramadol 325 mg - where can i buy tramadol for my dog
ReplyDeletehttp://www.integrativeonc.org/adminsio/buyklonopinonline/#cheap klonopin 60mg - klonopin withdrawal wikipedia
ReplyDeletebuy klonopin online how much klonopin and alcohol to overdose - klonopin online buy
ReplyDeletebuy tramadol without rx buy tramadol online - order tramadol online overnight
ReplyDeletehttp://www.njbic.org/online/buytramadol/#3750 tramadol overnight shipping - buy tramadol online
ReplyDelete